3 ms·
Interesting, their methodology is kinda khmm thought. When historians were going over the archives of the medieval Khivan Khanate, they found out from tax reco
by baybal2 9y ago
Interesting, their methodology is kinda khmm thought.
When historians were going over the archives of the medieval Khivan Khanate, they found out from tax records that ~12% of all households in Khiva and Bukhara had over 10kgs of gold.
Yet, if you were to apply the same methodology there, you will get same contradicting results
- EthanHeilman 9y ago>Yet, if you were to apply the same methodology there, you will get same contradicting results Can you explain this point further? Are you saying that Khanate tax records are inaccurate or that the Khivan Khanate were more wealthy than people today?
- baybal2 9y agoYes, people were saying for long that if Khiva was still a country today, it would be joining ranks of places like Andorra, or Luxembourg. Yet, people had to spend a big part of their income on simply food, water, clothing, and fuel
- notahacker 9y agoYou'd expect the top 10% of households' accumulated wealth over many generations to be a few decades of average annual income, especially if they're large households. US GDP per capita is around $50k and households in the top income decile all have household wealth in excess of a million dollars 10kgs of gold is about $40k, so is entirely consistent with Khivan GDP per capita being in the $500-$2000 range
- baybal2 9y ago>10kgs of gold is about $40k, so is entirely consistent with Khivan GDP per capita being in the $1k-$2k range 10kg of gold worth around $0.5m USD today. You are off by 10 times
- notahacker 9y agohaha, you're right (tbf I was only wrong by half an order of magnitude if I switch to 1800 gold prices!) It'd be interesting to see how the figures compare when taking into account how long the gold took to accumulate and the size of the household whose wealth it represented, and the wealth of the wider region. But more basic goods that enhance standards of living are probably a better representation of a civilization's wealth than the notional modern value of their gold hoards, especially if the gold was being hoarded precisely because the Silk Road couldn't supply them with things even today's poor can acquire
- lmm 9y agoGold is a relatively fixed supply, so the per-capita price of gold grows as population rises. It's not a good proxy for costs of living/happiness; if you want to measure household savings a better unit would be something like "how many calories of the cheapest available food could they buy?"