2 ms·
I find the premise fascinating because of how bad the Discover Weekly recommendations were when I was looking for a replacement for Rdio. Rdio did a great job o
by acdha 9y ago
I find the premise fascinating because of how bad the Discover Weekly recommendations were when I was looking for a replacement for Rdio. Rdio did a great job of suggesting new music but with Spotify I found myself constantly skipping tracks – combined with not having a way to play album tracks in order[1] I found no justification for using, much less paying for the service.
1. Yes, they claim to offer that for paid subscribers. As a former paid subscriber I can conclude only that they either lack a QA department or I ended up in the A/B bucket from hell.
- iaml 9y agoIt's really inconsistent - sometimes I add pretty much every single track from the discover weekly, and sometimes it's just a stream of garbage for multiple weeks straight. It also needs some time to adjust for your tastes - I got decent compilations only like 1 month in.
- acdha 9y agoI bailed after 3 months but the bimodal response distribution here is making me wonder whether they did have something like a broken A/B test, monitoring metrics which suppresses “outliers”, etc. which is keeping the team from seeing the subset of users who aren’t getting good results.
- smeyer 9y ago> combined with not having a way to play album tracks in order As a paid subscriber for several years, I've had no difficulties playing album tracks in order. I'm not sure what issue you were having, though.
- acdha 9y agoIf memory serves there was a button which was supposed to toggle shuffle and ordered playback. That didn’t work on either iOS or the desktop apps and the support team took a week to respond with a copy and paste of the instructions I’d said I was following in my original email. I’m totally willing to believe that it was some config bug but the effective lack of support was quite a disappointment, especially with Rdio for comparison.