7 ms·
Before I describe exactly what happened and how I discovered this pretty incredible violation of privacy, I'd like to point out that it ended up being a hardwar
by mhb 9y ago
Before I describe exactly what happened and how I discovered this pretty incredible violation of privacy, I'd like to point out that it ended up being a hardware defect in my Home Mini as well as an unspecified small number of others. Google never intended for it to happen and has reacted incredibly swiftly to rectify the situation.
- lisper 9y agoSure, but it's possible that the thing that Google never intended to happen was for the device to fail in such a blatantly obvious way. It does not rule out the possibility that Google intended for the device to (also) be able listen in a less blatantly obvious way. This story from today's Washington Post is relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15449826 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15449826
- andreime 9y agoIs this really an argument? I could just say there's no proof that google intended for the device to act as NSA proxy, and you could say there's no proof that ....
- lisper 9y ago> there's no proof that google intended for the device to act as NSA proxy Of course there isn't. This is the problem with surveillance: inherent in its nature is the fact that if it is done competently, its existence is indistinguishable from its absence. Note that I'm not saying that Google is acting in bad faith. What I'm saying is that the following is fallacious reasoning: 1. This incident turned out not to be a case of bad-faith surveillance. 2. Therefore, Google never engages in bad-faith surveillance. This is called the "hasty generalization" fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hasty_generalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hasty_generalization
- ilamont 9y agoit ended up being a hardware defect in my Home Mini According to Google. as well as an unspecified small number of others. Nothing to worry about, I'm sure. Probably no way to exploit those issues. Probably. Google never intended for it to happen Obviously, it's a rookie mistake that anyone could make. And that's why I'm willing to forgive and forget when it comes to multibillion dollar global businesses that make billions more off of the private information they gather and store. Just like I did after Equifax goofed earlier this year. And Yahoo the year before that. And … Look, I get it that the Google PR people have been super nice and accommodating and embarrassed about the whole thing. Maybe the writer is friends with people on the team, or there might be a job at Google down the road. And, of course, some writers don't want to lose access to free trials and potential interviews. But I really would like to see specialized news outlets show more backbone when it comes to screw-ups, and not downplay or gloss over serious privacy issues such as this, or take Google's word about what happened. It's a fair question to ask whether the problem(s) may still be present in every other Google device … and if they are potentially exploitable.
- jerf 9y agoIf you're going to be cynical, be properly cynical, not just half cynical. Nobody has any use for a spying hardware appliance that tells the user all about how it's listening to every word you say and logs it in a clearly visible location. Obviously this was not intentional on any level.
- russdpale 9y agoProve it with the code or what you are saying is 100% useless.
- krisives 9y agoThat ship has sailed regular news has been shown it can’t be trusted for the reasons you point out. Now we have “news” services like HaveIBeenPwned.com
- cl289 9y agoIt's not appropriate to say that "Google never intended for it to happen" without proof that that is the case, something which is almost impossible from outside Google. Yahoo and Equifax didn't intend for their breaches to happen either, but at least they do not benefit from them. Companies like Google and Facebook, which are in the advertising/datamining business, have an incentive for "accidental" slippages like road-mapping cars collecting wifi data, "we didn't know" sharing of virtually all user data sent over the internet without encryption with the NSA, over-complicated "privacy" settings, services for which user data "will be kept separate" morphing into "we now share user data across services...," and on and on. These are the most powerful non-governmental agencies in the world (and more powerful than almost all governments). Developers have to stop giving in particular Google a free pass on virtually everything. We need to stop setting Google DNS servers to be the default in software or in example code. We need to stop pretending that turning separate URL and search boxes into a single omnibox is a great convenience or efficiency of space and recognize that it's just more comprehensive collection of user data. We need to stop turning that ever-smaller remaining free space on the internet, the Web, into another massive spiderweb of signals sent to Google and Facebook, with as many as ten or twenty requests sent to Google from a typical webpage, many of which no longer function when these requests are blocked, because the functionality of the site, and not just the advertising, now comes from Google servers. Acquiescence to this status quo is easy and probably good for one's career, but it's also dangerous for democracy, dangerous for innovation, dangerous for independence of thought...