3 ms·
The notion that voice recognition is still hard enough to require doing it on a server somewhere still bothers me a lot. IMHO there should be no excuse for this
by phkahler 9y ago
The notion that voice recognition is still hard enough to require doing it on a server somewhere still bothers me a lot. IMHO there should be no excuse for this today. I understand that the device needs to be connected to the internet anyway, but this whole thing is such a gimmick it's not worth the privacy risk.
[edit] to clarify I think speech to text can be done on a device today, that's why this bothers me.
- Eridrus 9y agoNot sure what you mean exactly but this seems wrong. These devices do hotword (and speaker) recognition largely locally, but speech to text is done server side.
- kodablah 9y ago> voice recognition is still hard enough to require doing it on a server I'm not sure this is true, it's just that since they are phoning home anyways, why commit to extra local hardware to change sound bytes into text words? I would love to see an offline version of one of these with an easy API (do any high quality ones exist?). If I then wanted a generic Google request to give me the first Google response, so be it.
- hipitihop 9y agoThe awesome folk at Snips are challenging the idea that you can't do it locally https://snips.ai/technology/ https://snips.ai/technology/
- kodablah 9y agoNice. I wish every route I took there didn't require me to sign up. But I did find https://github.com/snipsco https://github.com/snipsco and am browsing now.
- smileysteve 9y ago> is still hard enough to require doing it on a server Hot word detection would suggest that voice is easy. "Accent" and "Intent" recognition is the hard part.