3 ms·
Sex at Dawn -- evolutionary biology misused
- TheSOB88 16y agoThis refutation of a book I've never heard of is not particularly interesting to me.
- javert 16y agoI strongly suspect this only made it to the front page because somebody voted multiple times with different accounts.
- hugh3 16y agoI've heard of it because there was a discussion about it last week: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1522325 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1522325 I was pretty skeptical of the book's claims, at least as they were summarized in that thread. So this review was interesting to me. (I had nothing to do with the submission though.) I still recommend The Red Queen by Matt Ridley to anyone interested in this subject.
- TheSOB88 16y agoThanks.
- _delirium 16y agoI could go down the front page making comments like that, I suppose? "This collaborative filtering plugin for a framework I don't use is not particularly interesting to me", or perhaps "This GUI elements library for an Adobe tool I don't use is not particularly interesting to me". People have heard of different things!
- robryan 16y agoI find it worse when something random about a technology you would never read apart from it being an article on HN is interesting to me. I've spent a whole heap of time reading stuff about Haskell(for one example) that is posted here but I haven't used it and don't know if I'll ever get around to learning it.
- robryan 16y agoTo really catalog everything that’s wrong with Sex at Dawn, I’d have to go back through at least five or six books (and probably more) and at least a dozen papers. It would take me all day. I feel the same way about The God Delusion, quiet enjoy the book and the arguments it puts forward but to actually take an unbiased look at all the arguments from many sources that are being put forward and notable refutations of these would take a seriously long time.
- berntb 16y agoDawkins isn't a "real" expert on e.g. theology. My favorite anti-religious author is Ingemar Hedenius, but that is afaik only in Swedish.
- datapimp 16y agoI found myself very irritated by quotes like this: "The book argues that humans are not “naturally” monogamous. That might be true. But Sex at Dawn doesn’t prove it." "males evolved a strong appetite for sexual novelty and a robust aversion to the overly familiar.” But they don’t have any evidence for that" If they don't, I think it is safe to assume it is because the authors assume their readers have a bit of life experience. And not because there aren't volumes of biological and historical evidence to support these claims if they wanted to include it. I just don't see these two points as even being controversial enough to be up for debate. You don't need that much romantic history to know that men have a strong appetite for sexual novelty, and that highly desirable men are not monogamous, that women know this ahead of time and are willingly complicit in their non-monogamy. Ok, I guess for the type of guy who would write these critiques, some things need to be spelled out on paper. You can just step outside in the world though and not need it to be.
- philwelch 16y agoThere are lots of things that we supposedly all know from life experience that are completely and totally false.
- datapimp 16y agoOn the point about male's appetite for variety and novelty, life experience can give you enough of a hunch that this is biologically innate, and not cultural. Stacks and Stacks of books on human history, recent tabloids, and the NSA's archive of everyone's web browser histories can pretty much confirm this hunch for you if you're still not convinced