2 ms·
Let's take race and gender off the table and consider this video instead: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FPsEwWT6K0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FPsEwWT6K
by smacktoward 9y ago
Let's take race and gender off the table and consider this video instead: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FPsEwWT6K0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FPsEwWT6K0
Here we see a bunch of (white, male) kids, all of whom are supposed to be experts in persuasive rhetoric, who have been trained to make arguments in a way that is utterly unpersuasive to anyone who has not spent years steeping in the world of academic debate. In fact, not only is it unpersuasive to the untrained ear, it is actively off-putting -- difficult and unpleasant to listen to.
Their method demonstrates both of the troubling points that TFA calls out:
1) They have been taught to cram more arguments into a given amount of time than their opponents can, so they race through their arguments at 350 words per minute like meth-fueled auctioneers; and
2) They have been taught to crowd out their opponents' time to make their own arguments by throwing out as many outrageous, nonsensical arguments as they can, since an argument their opponent does not refute will be scored by the judges as a point won regardless of its factual merit.
These things are fine if you see debate as a sort of abstract exercise. But if the point of debate is to train young people how to argue persuasively in the real world, they are disastrous, because they do the opposite. The "overload your opponent with nonsensical arguments" part teaches them to be aggressively obtuse, and the "spit out the words as fast as you can" part teaches them to communicate in a way that no lay person can understand or appreciate. And taken together they send the message that debating policy positions is an activity for a narrowly educated priesthood to do among themselves, not an activity in which the goal is to educate and persuade masses of normal people.
For all the good their teachers are doing these kids, they might as well be teaching them to argue in Latin. And that's a problem if you think of debate as a way to train future leaders in a democratic society.
- jackhack 9y agothat's it in a nutshell. Modern debate has nothing to do with logic, reasoning, rhetoric, facts, persuasiveness or eloquence. It is a perversion of the concept.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> so they race through their arguments at 350 words per minute like meth-fueled auctioneers Honestly, it kinda seems like they need a rule that forbids speaking faster than a certain rate, say 150 wpm or whatever a comfortable speaking rate is. I assume the debates have time limits to limit argument size, and speaking fast is just a cheap way of gaming that system. I'm surprised they've let it go on so long.