2 ms·
My guess on why they came up with the title they did is that they know a lot about physics, but spent very little time thinking about free will, and so picked a
by _delirium 16y ago
My guess on why they came up with the title they did is that they know a lot about physics, but spent very little time thinking about free will, and so picked a catchy if somewhat inaccurate title for PR reasons, and didn't bother to research it much. That seems in evidence from how little the paper discusses free will (it doesn't even acknowledge that there's controversy over its definition, and that their definition is not a particularly common one).
Seems sort of sloppy on the whole, and I really dislike those moves in science, since there's no scientifically good reason for it. Just pick the more precise, accurate title; there's no benefit to physics from attaching a loaded term like "free will" to something that has a clearer, more precise term for it, especially if you attach it inaccurately.
In my own papers, I try to do that, and then if I really want to note the connection to a philosophical concept, I note it as a possible connection in a future-work or possible-implications type of section: "if we take free will to be related to 'the stuff discussed in this paper', as some philosophers do (cite), our theorem may have implications for the existence of free will". But obviously that, while more honest, isn't as good PR as naming your thing the Free Will Theorem.
- Qz 16y agoIf you read the paper linked above, rather than the wikipedia article, it becomes pretty clear that they are very explicitly talking about free will and that the result of the theorem is directly related to the quantum mechanical science behind the thought experiment. So saying 'there's no scientifically good reason for it' is off the mark. It's also not specifically saying there is free will, it's only saying, if an experimenter has free will in deciding how to do an experiment, then the subatomic particles have the exact same kind of free will in the result that is shown from the measurement. If by some other method we conclude that an experimenter does not actually have this 'free will' thing, then the theorem doesn't really say anything about that. But the whole point of the theorem is directly related to the concept of free will, and naming it the Free Will Theorem is perfectly accurate.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]