3 ms·
I'd say probably most modern philosophers don't think that's the case. Daniel Dennett is a particularly strong proponent of the notion that free will is perfect
by _delirium 16y ago
I'd say probably most modern philosophers don't think that's the case. Daniel Dennett is a particularly strong proponent of the notion that free will is perfectly compatible with physical causation, and doesn't require agents to somehow magically be able to create gaps in it (and his view doesn't care much whether the causation is deterministic or has randomness in it).
Overview of the position: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/compatibilism/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/compatibilism/
- danbmil99 16y agothis. Read "Freedom Evolves" or the shorter precursor "Elbow Room". This confusion of free will with indeterminacy, and the specious connection with Quantum Mechanics (taken to the absurd extreme by Penrose) really muddies the water wrt AI/cogsci and the understanding of consciousness, qualia etc.
- Qz 16y agoThat's fine, except that quantum mechanics messes with the idea of determinate physical causation, and the Free Will Theorem (as well as the KS Paradox that it extends) is based on a particular proof that certain things (in this case, the measurement of the spin of a particle under certain circumstances) do not follow physical causation. What the FW Theorem shows is that if you take a situation in which we assume humans have free will, then the result is that subatomic particles also have that exact same kind of free will.