5 ms·
Lots of FUD as usual with these topics. The .NET Core CLI/SDK dev tool to build and package code is the only thing sending telemetry. It's not the main `dotnet
by manigandham 9y ago
Lots of FUD as usual with these topics.
The .NET Core CLI/SDK dev tool to build and package code is the only thing sending telemetry. It's not the main `dotnet` command itself nor anything in the runtime. The data is also available for anyone to analyze: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/core/tools/telemetry https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/core/tools/telemetry
It's definitely nothing out of the ordinary and is common practice among many tools and apps you already use. Your smartphone sends back way more data if you're that concerned.
There's also a warning the first time you use it, and if you're using something like this then it's a reasonable expectation that as a software developer you understand the message and how to disable it if you want to.
EDIT: the insights based on this telemetry are also interesting to look at and add further clarity: https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/dotnet/2017/07/21/what-weve-learned-from-net-core-sdk-telemetry/ https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/dotnet/2017/07/21/what-weve...
- bhrgunatha 9y ago> Lots of FUD as usual with these topics. > It's definitely nothing out of the ordinary and is common practice among many tools and apps you already use. Also as usual it's opt-out and NOT opt-in. People get riled because (usually) a) built in telemetry is almost always an unexpected and unannounced change - only to be discovered later. b) opt-in is the only approach that leaves your trust in tact - everyone uses opt-out because they know the majority of users people will not choose to opt in given a choice.
- manigandham 9y agoI don't see how it's unexpected when you get a message telling you when you first run it - and the only thing to do with this tool is to run commands explicitly. Most apps are opt-out though, the checkboxes are already checked and a message shown. I agree that it would be easier to just enter an option on the command line instead of typing the environment variable option.
- flukus 9y ago> I don't see how it's unexpected when you get a message telling you when you first run it - and the only thing to do with this tool is to run commands explicitly. What about when it's run through VS or some other tool that hides much of the text? How does it know that I've read this information when it could be buried in several thousand lines of output from itself and other tools like make or msbuild? Being explicit about opt-out is even less acceptable for command line tools than it is GUI based ones.
- cjsuk 9y agoExactly. It only takes one misconfiguration for your build server to call home. It should take one misconfiguration for your hold server to not call home. Slightly subtle inversion there.
- benaadams 9y ago> What about when it's run through VS or some other tool that hides much of the text? VS uses MSBuild rather than the dotnet cli (its also what the dotnet cli calls)
- throwaway613834 9y ago> I don't see how it's unexpected when you get a message telling you when you first run it https://github.com/dotnet/cli/issues/3093#issuecomment-326327218 https://github.com/dotnet/cli/issues/3093#issuecomment-32632...
- gcb0 9y ago> telemetry > opt-out Just like Google's chrome, flutter, android sdk, etc. Just like apple osx, xcode, etc. Macromedia everything. the list goes on. Even mozilla who had it right now have so many telemetry modules that most ignore the main setting about it. my point? I don't think I have any other than to highlight this is a lost cause and everyone should be eternally vigilant with everything :(
- justabystander 9y ago> There's also a warning the first time you use it If you'd actually read the issue before commenting, you'd realize that this behavior was added after people complained about the telemetry not being obvious. It's the sixth comment on the issue (by guardrex) - not even that far down. The very next comment is an MS contributor saying that he makes a good point that it wasn't obvious, and that they'd improve it in a future release. Which is why there's now a warning when using it. I mean, the link is old, but it should be understood that an issue on preview tooling from over a year ago might not represent the current state of the tooling. But yeah, on first release, all the notice you got was a blog post, if you even bothered to look for it. It's also a fair point that it's still not made very clear that what information is collected under what circumstances. It's a huge problem with Windows, so you can understand why people have their jimmies rustled even over something small. Especially since windows 10 makes it impossible to completely opt-out of telemetry. Even after disabling the visual options, it's still regularly calling out to Microsoft servers. Even if you disable the services, updates will turn them back on and other services will start it up. And then it chews through your system's CPU like it's starving. Which means it's probably collecting far more data than it needs. Finally, sometimes it's not even about what's collected or that there's an opt-out procedure. Sometimes just having a mechanism for transferring data can cause problems. 'sushihangover' comments on that issue that someone failed their HIPAA audit based on this behavior. I've no idea if it's an accurate example, but there are government, medical and enterprise environments where any non-sanctioned traffic is strictly prohibited and can cause liabilities. Telemetry needs to be easy, simple, and thorough in its opt-out mechanisms. Microsoft has failed its users on this frequently and recently. I don't think this particular instance is that bad, but they should be doing damage control in all products based on the public perception that they're spying on users. SQL Server Management Studio, on the other hand, is much better about its analytics opt-in request. Microsoft is a big company with varied practices. Not every division deserves a high-five about their privacy practices. > It's definitely nothing out of the ordinary and is common practice among many tools and apps you already use. Your smartphone sends back way more data if you're that concerned. Let MS take their knocks when they earn them. And it's totally fine if people point out that Microsoft has a problem with opting users into unwanted telemetry. Even if it's not important data, it's data that someone didn't volunteer to give up. It's a horrible, common-place practice that needs to end. Honestly, they might not need automatic telemetry if they just made volunteering information during a bug or slowdown significantly easier. If it was easy to, for example, enable telemetry for a Visual Studio session to track down why it runs like a whale, and then to review the information sent before it was sent, people would use it all the time to better the software. Instead, people turn off everything they can and don't bother to enable it (required for some MS feedback apps) to report issues because they don't know what'll sneak across. When your telemetry is easy, open, and transparent, people will gladly opt-in when they think it's needed. Or they can hide the data they care about and share the rest.
- cm2187 9y agoTo their credit the doc is pretty explicit on what they collect. Has Microsoft published anything similar for windows? All I have seen is very broad and generic statements, not a list of fields and a description of how they are obfuscated. [edit]: actually they do, and it is a pretty scary (and very long) reading, even the "basic" telemetry: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/basic-level-windows-diagnostic-events-and-fields https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/basic...
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoAnd it's still incomplete. They refuse to publish what happens for "security" level telemetry, which is sent in addition to basic and not disclosed.
- bad_user 9y ago> Your smartphone sends back way more data if you're that concerned. That's not true. My iPhone asked me if I want to share iPhone / iCloud analytics and I said no. This wasn't an opt-out, but an explicit question. I remember my Google Nexus asking me about it as well, including for Google's Keyboard. I said no and again no opt-out happened. And in fact it would be illegal to collect user telemetry in the EU without the user's explicit consent ;-)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nonamechicken 9y agoI have very limited apps in my phone. And I have disabled almost all Google creepware (except Google Play Services, Maps etc) and opted out of anything Google allows me to do. Still, I see this in Disconnect Pro: https://imgur.com/a/ajRbI https://imgur.com/a/ajRbI
- taneq 9y agoGoogle Play Services is THE creepware. It's essentially a MITM on most of your phone's live status information.
- bad_user 9y agoAre you asking me to debug your phone? Google Analytics is a service that can be used by websites, online services and mobile apps to track users. If I were to guess, those are requests made by the browser or by the apps that you have installed. I was also talking about a Nexus 6 phone, with the pure Android experience, not whatever Samsung or the others are doing. I don't feel this is relevant to the discussion at hand though.
- kuschku 9y agoThe little symbol at the right side means that this connection is initiated by the Google Services Framework, also called Google Play Services.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cjsuk 9y agoI’d like to add that just because something is common it doesn’t make it healthy or good for the user. Telemetry is a recent obsession of the industry and as trust declines this is the equivalent of stuffing a cigarette in the mouth of your customers and stealing their passports. It’s just not ok on any level.
- 2trill2spill 9y ago> Telemetry is a recent obsession of the industry and as trust declines this is the equivalent of stuffing a cigarette in the mouth of your customers and stealing their passports. Wow that went way over the top. Who knew Telemetry is carcinogenic or was considered stealing. Honestly it's hard to take the anti-telemetry crowd seriously when these types of arguments are used.
- nathanasmith 9y agoThere are more axes of comparison than literal interpretation.
- tym0 9y agoI agree, if you make telemetry opt-in, you might as well not even try doing telemetry in the first place. However I think the way to disable it is a bit user hostile, maybe a prompt when run interactively for the first time and a env var for when running in automated environment.