2 ms·
it's ok. Generally if you post a sketchy scientific statement, say, something by an advocate of homeopathy, a common retort will be, "it's not in a peer-review
by dnautics 9y ago
it's ok. Generally if you post a sketchy scientific statement, say, something by an advocate of homeopathy, a common retort will be, "it's not in a peer-reviewed journal". Of course in the vast majority of cases not being in a "peer-reviewed journal" is a sign that the work is shoddy, but those it comes at the expense of elevating the converse statement - that something in a "peer-reviewed journal" is necessarily of good scientific workmanship.
There is a weak connection between being in a "peer-reviewed journal", having undergone sufficient peer review (in the classical sense), and possibly the irony is that the connection is has a negative correlation with profile at the high end. (it's probably positively correlated at the low end).