3 ms·
> I had Simpson's references sprinkled here and there, that sort of thing. I should offer to read your paper before criticising it, but I can't even begin to u
by chrisseaton 9y ago
> I had Simpson's references sprinkled here and there, that sort of thing.
I should offer to read your paper before criticising it, but I can't even begin to understand why you would think that references to a TV programme would help make a paper more readable. What if you don't happen to watch the Simpsons? Is the paper then even more opaque because none of the references mean anything?
I quite like the bland academic voice - because it lets me focus on what I came for which is the science. I don't want to be amused, and I don't want academics wasting time trying to be witty or fit in references to whatever TV programme is fashionable.
I want just the science, please! Delivered as clearly and simply as possible.
- deong 9y agoThere are parts of the standard academic paper that aren't really necessary for understanding it. You typically have background on the problem, for example. I can't say for certain I didn't lose a reader, but none of the references detracted from meaning in my view.