6 ms·
In a document prepared for a Korean trade delegation to Silicon Valley in May, and obtained by IEEE Spectrum, Strobe claimed that its prototype lidar had a rang
by mhb 9y ago
In a document prepared for a Korean trade delegation to Silicon Valley in May, and obtained by IEEE Spectrum, Strobe claimed that its prototype lidar had a range of 300 meters, a processing time of fewer than 45 milliseconds, and cost less than $100. It also noted that its first product would be commercially available in the spring of 2018.
https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self-driving/gm-cruise-snaps-up-solidstate-lidar-pioneer-strobe-inc https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sel...
- was_boring 9y agoIs this retail, wholesale or cost to make prices? As someone who works on their own cars, electric and self-driving cars have me scared that it will not be possible in the future.
- Shivetya 9y agoI figure a great deal of this will be standardized with modules you swap out like you do a water pump and sensors like light assemblies. plus it is not like all these older cars are going anywhere. people vastly over estimate how fast self driving cars will arrive and just as much the electric only revolution
- danblick 9y agoIMHO it's fun to think about the economics of autonomous vehicles. For example, here's a neat article on "second order effects" of electric and autonomous cars [1]. (examples: Increased use of autonomous cars could mean less space lost to parking lots in cities. Higher utilization for cars could mean faster turnover (~3 years/car instead of ~10).) One thing to think about: autonomous cars might make a big difference for car-sharing services or trucking, but they're less essential when you're driving the car yourself and parking in your garage. I think traditional cars will be around for a while. (Particularly in lower-density areas where there's less demand for ride-sharing services.) This article [2] suggests regular cars may be around until 2050 or so: "According to IHS, a firm that provides automotive forecasts and insights, sales of autonomous cars, including driver control, will begin by 2025 and could reach 11.8 million in 2035; sometime after 2050, says IHS, almost all vehicles will be autonomous." So your hobby is probably good for another 30 years at least? [1] http://ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2017/3/20/cars-and-second-order-consequences http://ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2017/3/20/cars-and-second... [2] http://senseable.mit.edu/papers/pdf/20150803_Claudel_Ratti_FullSpeed_McKinsey.pdf http://senseable.mit.edu/papers/pdf/20150803_Claudel_Ratti_F...
- toomuchtodo 9y agoCan you imagine how much additional livable space is going to be available across the world if people convert their garages into another room? Assuming 12 ft by 22 ft (minimum space for a one car garage, rounding down nation wide to be conservative), that's 264 sq ft. In 2016, there were about 125.82 million households in the United States. That's 33.216 billion sq ft of additional living space! They say they're not making more land; I'd argue we're going to be way more efficient with the land we have in the future.
- maxerickson 9y agoYou are counting households that live in apartments there. And lots of garages aren't attached (on this block there are 12 garages with 1 being attached to the house). Another way to say 30 billion square feet is 15 million to 30 million housing units. A drop in the bucket of the additional housing that will be needed globally in the coming decades.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> You are counting households that live in apartments there. Good call, my mistake. > Another way to say 30 billion square feet is 15 million to 30 million housing units. A drop in the bucket of the additional housing that will be needed globally in the coming decades. I don't think this is the case. Population is on the decline in the industrialized world. Africa, Indian, and China need a whole lot of housing though. https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth/ https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth/
- maxerickson 9y agoCensus predicts that the US population will grow by tens of millions just in the next 15 years. But note that I said global to begin with. I think letting people move around freely is a fine thing. This link shows a projection Census did in 2012: https://www.census.gov/newsroom/cspan/pop_proj/20121214_cspan_popproj.pdf https://www.census.gov/newsroom/cspan/pop_proj/20121214_cspa... They seem to have killed a bunch of urls, but they do tables of future expected population. The US population is very much expected to exceed 400 million before too long.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago> Is this retail, wholesale or cost to make prices? I'd guess it's the estimated cost to manufacture, say, half a million units. GM sold 574,876 Silverados in 2016[1] a new headlamp assembly for a 2016 Silverado costs about $600 each on eBay. 1. http://www.businessinsider.com/best-selling-cars-trucks-vehicle-america-2016-2017-1/?r=AU&IR=T/#19-jeep-grand-cherokee-212273-81-2 http://www.businessinsider.com/best-selling-cars-trucks-vehi...
- joshvm 9y agoProbably fabrication cost, given that it's a prototype. It's a research project so their estimates are a bit pie in the sky right now. Until it's mass produced it'll be expensive, but who knows, maybe GM will pull it off. Notable that this is an FMCW system. Very few commercial players use frequency modulation, they all use either AM or pulsed lasers. Rep rate is not so good. 45 ms = 20Hz maximum. That's poor compared to Velodyne (15kHz or so per transceiver) or surveying stations which can push 1MHz. Even hobbyist systems like the Scanse manage 4kHz. I'd guess that the problem is, in part, because you need to chirp for a certain amount of time. Pulsed systems often use avalanche diodes that trigger from relatively few photons. It's 1D, so you've still got to scan it which is bad for robustness. I'm more excited for solid state LIDAR that uses beam shaping (or however they're doing it) to scan without moving parts. The range is good though, FMCW is great for that (and the accuracy should be good too). The main advantage of FMCW is that you can still get the high accuracy of AMCW systems (i.e. at a lower bandwith than direct time of flight), but you don't have the phase ambiguity problem that AM does.
- saulrh 9y ago> Rep rate is not so good. 45 ms = 20Hz maximum. If that's their per-sample time, they probably would've dissolved by now after admitting total defeat - 20 Hz is totally unusable for navigation. I'd guess that that's something more like maximum latency from real world to computer, either due to deep pipelining or because they communicate data frames rather than a stream of individual samples. Very easy for that kind of thing to fall through when talking to the media.
- Judgmentality 9y ago> 20 Hz is totally unusable for navigation. What? I've seen lots of autonomous robots that operate at 10 Hz, including mission critical systems for the military. Compared to cameras, which might operate as fast as 60 Hz (but are far more likely to operate at 30 Hz or a fraction thereof) I am confused where you're getting these numbers from. Do you have any citations?
- 9y ago