3 ms·
Antibiotics: don't make it into your beef in an amount that will affect your life. You can consume more drugs by drinking tap water in LA. Hormones: I guess we
by exabrial 9y ago
Antibiotics: don't make it into your beef in an amount that will affect your life. You can consume more drugs by drinking tap water in LA.
Hormones: I guess we should ban birth control as well, correct? Because that's all it is...
But, I believe in a free society, so if people wish to remain ignorant of science, that's their prerogative. But it's important to recongize those are just marketing campaigns: there is nothing "healthier" about eating beef raised antibiotic/hormone free, all other things being equal (living conditions for the animals).
- jimktrains2 9y agoThe issue many people have with antibiotics and hormones aren't always about what is made into the food. (Though, yes, there are a lot of people that worry about that.) Issues around proper usage of antibiotics, especially now with the constant emergence of new resistant strains of bacteria is one concern, along with proper disposal and excess dosage making it into the environment. There are also animal welfare issues and concerns, I'm unfortunately not well-versed enough in ranching to know how true those are. (And as a vegetarian find growing animals for food repulsive to begin with.) Hormones stem again from animal welfare issues. It's unfair to just toss out all concerns over hormones and antibiotics just because some concerns aren't merited or as merited.
- seszett 9y ago> Hormones: I guess we should ban birth control as well, correct? Because that's all it is... We don't usually give birth control hormones to male humans. I don't know if they are bad when they are given to animals (it's forbidden here in Europe) but female hormones are definitely not good to developing children or adult males. They're just good/neutral (well, not functionally neutral of course, but not causing unplanned disruption) to adult females because they're part of their normal physiology.
- exabrial 9y ago> We don't usually give birth control hormones to male humans. This comment presents a false premise. The amounts in beef are ridiculously small, especially when compared to other foods. Any "advantages" to "hormone free beef" are pseudoscience and a marketing campaign, and that's it.
- seszett 9y agoI did say that I don't know if there's a problem with hormones given to animals. My point was the original comment implying that hormones are not harmful because they are used for birth control, which is shortsighted and plain wrong.
- jackhack 9y agoYet "microdosing" seems to be a thing in SV & the Bay. Who to believe? Bottom line: You clearly don't mind the idea of additional hormones in farm-raised beef. That's great you've made a decision based on your risk assessment and information. I'm simply asking to be extended the same courtesy. I want information to make my own informed choice.