7 ms·
It annoys me that fruit/vegs has to "look good". Anyone that has grown their own carrots know that the results you get are far from the "ideal carrot" :') That
by exabrial 9y ago
It annoys me that fruit/vegs has to "look good". Anyone that has grown their own carrots know that the results you get are far from the "ideal carrot" :')
That being said, I believe GMO food is the future. It's safe and environmentally friendly: we can use far less land and water to produce larger amounts of crops.
- herrity4 9y agoI think were shooting ourselves in the foot. We did the same with antibiotics. Disease gets worse and we make super bugs and are more and more reliant on our defenses. Eventually GMO will be the same thing. You won't be able to grow nonGMO crops because we have weaponized the crop killers to such a high degree.
- kobeya 9y agoNews flash : “nonGMO” crops are already genetically modified from wild plants, just through a more painstaking process of cross breeding and artificial selection over random mutations. This is already happening and would happen anyway.
- herrity4 9y agoAll genetic modifications aren't created equal. If you can get to it from cross breeding, it's probably not that foreign a trait, but if you to say splice pea DNA with mesquito DNA or something, that result could have consequences consumers would rather not worry about when buying produce. I'm not saying it's a fine dilineation or anything and I'm not anti science, but there are more nuanced regulations in food labeling today than GMO nonGMO.
- kobeya 9y agoWith the availability of genetic sequencing you can get from anywhere A -> B in the reachable genetic search space through selective breeding, and still qualify for regulatory purposes as non-GMO. You can get out of that loophole by prohibiting the non-GMO label for anything that was bred based on direct genome sequencing, but that's a game a whack-a-mole as I come up with another scheme. And at the end, what's the point? Regulate what you actually care about in the food, not what process was taken to get there.
- sampo 9y ago> Disease gets worse They don't get worse. The antibiotic-resistant "superbugs" are not actually super in any other way. They just have a resistance to antibiotics. In other ways, they are just normal bugs, not super. Just like vaccinations make people immune to certain diseases, but doesn't give us any other superpowers.
- herrity4 9y agoIt's not an apples to apples analogy, but if let's say there's a parasite that activates on an enzyme present in tomatoes. You respond by modifying tomatoes to produce less of that enzyme. The result is only parasites capable of reproducing with smaller and smaller quantities of that enzyme present are able to survive which shows huge gains. However, this would prove to be extremely detrimental to tomatoes producing "normal" quantities of said enzyme. It's a hypothetical and a strained one at that, but all I'm saying is there are often long term consequences to short term gains that may not be considered in a prisoners' dillema ecological/economic scenario. I'm not convinced market forces alone would be able to actually fix problems of this nature, but I'm inclined to consumer education over under labeling as a component in the mix.
- sampo 9y agoParasites don't "activate on an enzyme". That is not how parasitism works. Also, pest insects are not parasites. They're just insects that like to eat tomatoes, just like we do. Eating food is not parasitism.
- herrity4 9y agoEh, it's a rough example. Plants produce something plant eater (fungal, bacterial, insect) is attracted to and we're modifying the levels. Semantics of the relationship be damned, there can be evolutionary consequences.
- sampo 9y agoPlants produce food: starch and sugars (and a bit of protein). We're not modifying the levels of those. The apple case is about modifying the levels of an enzyme, polyphenol oxidase [1]. But that is not what plant-eaters are interested in. They're interested in the food in an apple, not some enzyme levels. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphenol_oxidase https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphenol_oxidase
- mustacheemperor 9y agoThis is disingenuous. Will cold climates somehow adapt to better kill cold-hardy GMO potatoes? The same mechanics behind antibiotic resistance don't apply universally to what we use GMO for.
- herrity4 9y agoSure, it's not 1:1, and I don't think all GMOs are created equal. I'm just saying chasing profits in the short term might have unintended long term consequences that could be avoided in certain situations.
- mustacheemperor 9y agoThen you should have said that instead of implying an entirely different, unsupportable point.
- jimktrains2 9y agoThe "ugly vegetable" movement is slowly picking up (or maybe just in my social circle). Like you I grew up with a garden and it never dawned on me until college that people shun "ugly" produce. I also believe in the promise of GMO food. Unfortunately the business practices of the main players get wrapped in with junk science for many in the anti-GMO crowed. It becomes an involved process to convince someone I don't think that someone's business practices are ethical while I admire the science they do, and isn't always received well.
- fred_is_fred 9y agoMy grocery store has a special shelf for ugly fruits and veggies sold at a discounted rate. I buy when there's something I need.
- craftyguy 9y agoTotally. I'm a big fan of spending far less to buy "ugly" produce from the grocery store's "ugly product" section. It tastes exactly the same, and all turns into poop regardless of how it looks on the shelf.
- ajnin 9y agoThere is a problem though, GMO and agricultural research in general is oriented towards making produce survive better the transportation, have better yields, look better in the shelves so that they are sold more easily, etc. The goal is to improve the industrial processes, but there is little regard for the actual nutritional value of the food and the health implications. I fear that with GMO we're going to go much farther and more quickly in that direction than we've been able so far using only "traditional" selective breeding. And that's already had a big impact on fruits and vegetable which have now less vitamins and minerals than varieties that used to be grown a few decades ago.
- pasbesoin 9y agoMy question/concern is related, although for the moment specifically addressing these apples. "Brown" is a sign of aging. And generally, fruit and vegetable nutritional content declines with aging. So, by hindering these apples' browning, is this essentially facilitating their selling us a less nutritious product?
- xythian 9y agoThere's at least one startup trying to take advantage of the ugly produce gap. I've only received one box so far, but it was all great produce and some of it quite hard to figure out what made it imperfect. https://www.imperfectproduce.com/ https://www.imperfectproduce.com/
- joshstrange 9y agoSeems interesting but as with a lot of things, it doesn't deliver to my city. I really would like a platform to "watch" certain startups and get notified when they come to my city. Yes I could sign up for their newsletter but I don't care to get all the spam until they do come to my city.
- ilurkedhere 9y agoIf your goal is environmental health, using less land, less water, then you're better off tackling the larger cause: animal production. It dwarfs crops by those metrics.
- sampo 9y agoThere is no reason why we couldn't do both at the same time, though.
- tzs 9y ago> That being said, I believe GMO food is the future. It's safe and environmentally friendly There is nothing in GMO technology that prevents making an unsafe or environmentally unfriendly GMO food. It's just a tool, one that gives food makers power to produce a wider variety of new foods more rapidly than they could with non-GMO techniques. Whether they use it to produce safe foods or dangerous foods is up to each food maker.
- simonsarris 9y ago> Anyone that has grown their own carrots know that the results you get are far from the "ideal carrot" :') To get good carrots, make sure you are digging/disturbing at least 8 inches of soil so that the carrots can easily grow downwards. Otherwise, when they face resistance, they will fatten and sprout other carrot limbs, etc.
- scruple 9y agoCarrots are an interesting one. In rural America, where I grew up in the midwest, it used to be that you could fill an entire truck bed for $10 US with the "ugly" carrots from farmers who had large rejection stocks. No idea if this is still done today but I have no reason to believe it isn't.
- megaman22 9y agoWe used to do the same thing with the drop apples that fell off the trees before they were picked. If you picked ALL of them, to clean up, we used to get them for $1 per 100 lb grain bag. Some of them were mush or partly rotted, or just ugly, but who really cares, when they're going to be mostly pig food? There were always enough nice apples to save out a couple bags for freezing or making pies or applesauce.