8 ms·
Video Games Satisfy Basic Human Needs
- runj__ 9y ago"Eager to steal a bicycle from a 10-year-old boy?" There have never been children in any GTA game.
- philippnagel 9y agoHuh, I never noticed that. Some trivia: http://gta-myths.wikia.com/wiki/Children http://gta-myths.wikia.com/wiki/Children.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jlebrech 9y agoIf you want to steal bikes from kids you have to play Bully
- khalilravanna 9y agoI'm sure this isn't what they meant but I think technically you could steal a bike from a 10 year old player in GTA Online now.
- kaybe 9y agoTo be fair, the 10-year-old can probably curb-stomp you online, so the usual difference in power that makes 10-year-olds off-limits is not there.
- Density 9y agoe: To clear things up I'm not criticizing Bartle's work here.
- pagnol 9y agoDoes this sentence sound like bullshit to you? Why?
- berdon 9y ago^^ I read "Hearts, Clubs, Diamonds, Spades: Players Who Suit MUDs" while developing my own MUD and it seemed _very_ applicable. Both from a gamer and a developer perspective. I'm not sure the FA's reference to that paper makes it necessarily bad.
- jblz 9y agoI don't think your criticism is very obvious. Can you elaborate? The Bartle Test is a pretty common tool / consideration in gaming psych & gamified interfaces.
- Density 9y agoI personally have no issue with the test. Players have different preferences when it comes to video games. What I have a problem with is researchers attempting to drawn a relationship between video game preferences and basic needs. To me this reeks of Jack Thompson.
- ionised 9y ago> Players have different preferences when it comes to video games. The point is why they have these preferences, and what these preferences lead to in terms of how different people might approach the same game. You could present a counter article instead of just telling us how much you don't like the premise of this one. Anecdotally, I know blasting the crap out of demons in Doom does a pretty good job of channelling my anger. It's cathartic and not something society typically caters for. A lot of games are about building efficient systems, which naturally would attract people that like solving problems with designs and creativity. You are dismissing the entire premise of the article based on a dislike for one man that tried (and failed) to convince America that GTA was a murder simulator. A man that (if you bother to read up on what he is up to now) doesn't even believe any of the shit he said back then and actually apologised for it.
- jlebrech 9y agoRisk and reward
- indescions_2017 9y agoBartle's four quadrants is standard in gamification practise. Your assessment of its validity probably tracks with how effective you feel gamification can be in altering human behavior ;) The more interesting modern use case is when people say: "there's this game on my phone I play a lot that helps me with my anxiety." And it's usually something trivial like a free Puzzle Bobble clone that was developed in a week at zero-budget. But for that player, its a lifeline, a coping mechanism. That's very interesting to me. What is it about this gameplay mechanic that relieves stress? It can't just be escape. To me it seems it has to tap into something more intrinsic than archetypal "hunter-gatherer" era categories.
- wildpeaks 9y agoExtra Credits even has an excellent episode on Bartle's taxonomy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxpW2ltDNow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxpW2ltDNow
- drhayes9 9y agoI've wondered a lot about that too. I bet (and would love to see hard research on) Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing as it applies to games. Like, if the game has rhythmic elements and alpha-state gameplay with EMDR-type eye movements on top... I bet you've got a therapy machine right there.
- rubinelli 9y agoI cannot speak for everyone, but in my experience, it is the sense of efficacy and control. You may feel like you don't have any control over your life, but at least you can rule over those colorful bubbles, and be pretty good at it.
- nkozyra 9y ago> Except, of course, aside from its pre-set storyline, Grand Theft Auto doesn’t prescribe any of these things. This is not a fair characterization of the game. Yes, you can avoid doing those morally reprehensible things but not if you actually want to play the game. In much the same way if you feel it's morally wrong to stomp goombas, you can avoid doing so in Super Mario Bros. But unlike the latter, you cannot proceed in GTAV without engaging in some of those undesirable actions. The notion that we're making these choices independent of the game is disingenuous.
- whamlastxmas 9y agoThere's a million fun things to do in GTA without hurting anyone, to be fair.
- nkozyra 9y agoAbsolutely, I just don't think it's sincere to present it as though GTA itself doesn't offer a ton of context to push oneself in this direction. The premise pivots on the notion that we're doing these things of our own volition.
- Retra 9y agoIt is our own volition to care about finishing the game, and also to not care about inflicting imaginary suffering on imaginary ragdolls.
- pasquinelli 9y agoif you're there to play the game then you're there to let it manipulate you, so you made your choice before you started playing.
- True-Saber 9y agoPeople make these things called mods/cheats, which allow you to manipulate the game. I don't want to play through Ravenholm again, so I use the command to go to my preferred level.
- jblz 9y agoThe STTNG Episode "The Game"[1] comes to mind :) In the show, the device physically stimulates the pleasure centers of the brain to the point that players are highly addicted & easily manipulated. I interpret it as allegory to the way "real" video games leverage variable rewards & other reinforcement to do something similar. 1. http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/The_Game_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/The_Game_(episode)
- AmIFirstToThink 9y agoI think we as society have lost the ability to give the kids a creative space, that used to be a mile away from homes where they can play in the sand and bushes and water, and just be kids, without adult supervision. Video games let kids experience creation. Video games are satisfying an evolutionary need. I think nautil.us should write an article on positive effects of mobile phone connectivity. The snobs are looking down on that just like they are on video games.
- actionscripted 9y agoThis could help explain the massive popularity of sandbox titles like Minecraft.
- ourmandave 9y ago...they can play in the sand and bushes and water, and just be kids, without adult supervision. Recreate Lord of the Flies with GTAV? =)
- pm90 9y agoUrban centers through most of human history have lacked a lot of open spaces, and kids have grown up fine. Human brains are incredibly resilient, and you can raise healthy kids even in dense urban areas. The problem seems to be more about the constant stimuli that comes from internet enabled devices and video games. I grew up without access to much video games or the internet but that made me dream up entire fantasy worlds as a kid, because I was bored. I don't think the current environment allows kids that kind of space to just be bored and create things via imagination. I'm not a child specialist though so I might be totally wrong about this.
- naravara 9y ago>Urban centers through most of human history have lacked a lot of open spaces For most of human history transportation through urban centers was done primarily on foot and roads were designed to facilitate that. Contemporary urban planning is designed around speedily moving motorized vehicles through and the streets, such as they are, are rivers of traffic that pedestrians have to hurry themselves across during the short windows of time that cars aren't speeding by. The invention of the automobile has been terrible for letting kids roam around. On the flip-side of the dangers they face in urban centers, the ones growing up in newer suburban areas lack the density to have an appreciable amount of kids of similar ages within walking/biking distance of each other. Many older style, "streetcar" suburbs do, but we haven't build many of those in the past 30 or so years.
- burkaman 9y ago> For these researchers, incredibly, enjoyment is not the primary reason why we play video games. Enjoyment is not the primary motivation—“it is rather,” they wrote, “the result of satisfaction of basic needs.” Isn't this just the definition of enjoyment? Satisfying basic needs is the only reason anybody does anything.
- pm90 9y agoIts a good question, and I hope someone with more knowledge also responds to this, but I don't think they are the same thing. There is a difference between things that give you pleasure and things that you enjoy doing. e.g. you might not enjoy doing drugs if you're an addict but its almost always pleasurable. So I think enjoying something is more long term, higher level aspect than pleasure, which seems more short term. Which explains a lot why people engage in activities which they may not really enjoy, but get the short term pleasure hit. e.g. binge eating, binge TV watching etc
- pizza 9y agoIf I were a quiet and shy neighbor, and you saw me carrying a small wicker basket with a cloth covering the basket's contents with me everywhere I went, year after year after year, wouldn't you desperately want to know what was in the basket? ie there are drives (eg water when thirsty) but there are other desires too
- dugditches 9y agoTo quote part of a recent Alan Kay post here: "We are set up genetically to learn the environment/culture around us. If we have media that seems to our nervous systems as an environment, we will try to learn those ways of thinking and doing, and even our conception of reality."
- hypertexthero 9y agoSimon Parkin is a good writer. See also Coming Of Age With Video Games — https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/coming-of-age-with-video-games https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/coming-of-age-wi...
- graphitezepp 9y agoI am glad they took the time to mention Super Smash Bros Melee. That game took over my life for a time, and in hindsight it was because it was the medium that made me feel as if I was expressing myself honestly for the first time.