3 ms·
No, I don't think you're sorry to be pedantic. If you really were sorry, you would have made amends (e.g., deleting your comment) instead of doubling down. Eve
by geofft 9y ago
No, I don't think you're sorry to be pedantic. If you really were sorry, you would have made amends (e.g., deleting your comment) instead of doubling down.
Everyone understood just what you meant. (Every single person, literally.) Your pedantic observation was not new. People just thought it contributed nothing to the conversation. Around here you get downvoted for being off-topic, not just for being wrong.
There is a perfectly good pedantic-mark: it's called not replying in the first place.
- quadrangle 9y agoBy the time I noticed the downvoting and realized that I was a bit excessively pedantic, HN wouldn't let me edit or delete!! So I had no choice in making amends besides ignoring the whole thing or replying. But I was indeed only partly sorry. Sometimes being pedantic is okay, what I meant was that I was sorry for being pedantic without explicitly acknowledging it. To explain non-pedantically: I think it's interesting to note and acknowledge the tendency of people to have the wrong impression of over-engineered here. I think admitting that thought is appropriate, and I'd like to know how widespread it is. I also was certainly NOT clear that everyone was downvoting just because my comment was off-topic. I thought it might indeed be people misunderstanding me.