7 ms·
Don’t Be Scared About the End of Capitalism, Be Excited to Build What Comes Next
- pb060 9y agoGrowth based capitalism is so resilient that it will eventually end, but it will probably happen too late, either because of a world war or most probably natural disasters that will affect the most basic needs like food production and water resources. I have been quite excited about the concept of alternative, local based economies, and I'm amazed by communities that try and manage to build one, but I think they are too small to be a viable solution. Still, reading articles like this give me a bit of hope.
- cisanti 9y agoYou can start with your family and relatives. Live close to each other, help each other. Best communism ever and it actually works because you care. Of course the urbanism makes things difficult but nothing besides greed is forcing people to cities. The biggest problem in my eyes is that people lack any gratitude for everything we have in the western world. Maybe because I was born in soviet union I think about it more, but I'm sometimes guilty too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- simion314 9y agoEdit: this comment was intended as a reply but the original comment I was replying was deleted... My understanding is that the authors were referring at consumerism, like changing your phone because a new version appeared, or rich people owning a few cars or plains or yachts, maybe too many resources are wasted for nothing good. My wish is that we will arrive to a Star Trek like system, but in the series is shown that before we reached that we fist had an extreme capitalism phase then a third world war, so I am afraid of a big blood bath before things balance.
- gutnor 9y agoI guess the elephant in the room that the article ironically illustrate is that "we have no idea what's coming next". The article reads a bit like "You are suffering from a well know incurable illness, you are going to die very soon. By don't despair, think all the things you will be able to do if a cure is found! Even better, some people are even looking for one!" But that's not the real problem. Humanity is very bad at transitioning, it mostly still works in the natural fashion: keep the survivors if any. That's the real fear, not where we are going, but how we are going to get there without war, massive death toll, ... Before capitalism is abandoned, we need Capitalism 1.1, 1.2 then 1.3 and we need it before wrecking Earth completely or before the growth engine is completely broken whichever come first.
- dandare 9y agoAs usual with most debates about Capitalism, this article indiscriminately mixes economic systems with political ideologies. Capitalism is not the opposite of Communism, Democracy is (one of the core ideas of Communism is the dictatorship of the proletariat). And there is not a single Western state with purely capitalist economy, what we see around us are mixed economies with smaller or bigger level of redistribution, limits on private property and elements of social security. I would really like to see which one of the central characteristics of Capitalism - private property, capital accumulation, wage labor, voluntary exchange, price system, competitive markets - is no longer supported by "51% of young people in the United States no longer support the system of capitalism".
- humanrebar 9y agoI suspect people are meaning different things when they say "capitalism". Most of its detractors are against corporate cronyism, which I think almost everyone is against. I also think the effects of that cronyism are unfairly attached to capitalism when, as you are alluding to, there's nothing in capitalism itself about the specifics people complain about in the status quo. Here's capitalism: a recognition of certain human rights (oriented around property) and a thesis that crowd-sourcing economic choices is better than centrally controlling them. I'd be interested in hearing someone who is against capitalism argue against either of those things.
- dandare 9y agoI think you said it better than me.
- mmsimanga 9y agoAgree 100%. To add my own take. No I haven't read Marx just my observations. Humans, rather human nature is the weakest link with whichever system is implemented. Communism seems to result in dicatorships. Cronyism exists in both communism and capitalism. I honestly think very few people once in power can resist starting to believe in their own hubris. This often results in all sorts problems including wars and cronyism. I think electoral systems that limit people to a few years in power are the only way. Same should apply to cooporate entities unless you founded the company.
- jondubois 9y agoGrowth is great if everyone involved in the system has a fair opportunity to partake in that growth and if it creates real value (not just growth in stock price). However, opportunities for wealth redistribution are increasingly rare these days so the only way to level the playing field seems to be through the collapse of the financial system. Personally, I stand to benefit financially from chaos. If the stock market collapses tomorrow and a large number of public corporations go bankrupt then that means more business opportunities small (self-sustaining/profitable) startups to take their place and therefore more opportunities for me as a shareholder of such a startup.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoPersonally, I stand to benefit financially from chaos. It's hard to really know, the thing about revolutions is you just end up with a new set of leaders, human nature doesn't change much along the way.
- humanrebar 9y ago> ...the only way to level the playing field seems to be through the collapse of the financial system. It's worth noting that when the financial system goes through a down cycle, the government bails out the politically and economically powerful, propping up existing economic inequalities. This is not a capitalist policy. I think capitalism mostly has a branding problem.
- jondubois 9y agoI think that the bailing out of corporations during the 2008 crisis was in a large part the result of corporate lobbying; which is a natural byproduct of capitalism. Capitalist moralists love to point out that 'bailing out' is anti-capitalist but at the same time they seem to ignore to the fact that that government manipulation by corporations is an integral part of capitalism in the first place. So you end up with two sets of capitalists; moral capitalists and immoral capitalists unwittingly collaborating with one another. It was very convenient for a lot of passive 'moral' shareholders that the government just happened to step in to bail out their favourite stocks.
- titzer 9y agoCapitalism won't die. It's an umbrella term for a lot of different economic arrangements where private individuals hold the main concentrations of wealth. As other commenters mentioned, capitalism is not a political system. What will die is growthism (https://hbr.org/2013/10/this-isnt-capitalism-its-growthism-and-its-bad-for-us https://hbr.org/2013/10/this-isnt-capitalism-its-growthism-a...): the organization of our economic systems around the assumption of perpetual exponential growth. It's simple math that this will fail, no matter how many virgin markets there are in developing countries. We can already see growth failing; it is likely to completely collapse within the lifetimes of most people in this forum. But even when growthism fails, some form of private ownership will survive.
- humanrebar 9y ago> It's an umbrella term for a lot of different economic arrangements where private individuals hold the main concentrations of wealth. There's nothing in capitalism itself about concentrated wealth. Or are you saying the term is being misapplied?
- eksemplar 9y agoI'm not a pessimist because capitalism is ending, I'm a pessimist because it's not. Right now we're seeing a shift in who benefits and an inequality crisis, but absolutely nothing is being done to change the course of our economy away from capitalism. Uber isn't a collective/shared economy, it's a taxi service without labour rights. So what we're really seeing isn't the end of capitalism it's the end of democracy and individual rights, and anyone who's read any bit of cyberpunk knows what comes next isn't going to be exciting. It'll be dystopian as fuck, and we're approaching the point where the powers can render revolution almost impossible through tech. Sure it could lead to something better, if you're optimistic, but then I wonder if you've been paying attention to the state of individual freedom these past years. Surveillance is at an all time high, big data can predict our lives and we've started hating our neighbors.
- gremlinsinc 9y agoUnfortunately.. I think you're absolutely right... We definitely need to change course... Especially when AI/Automation begin taking more jobs and the proletariat don't even have the ability to get a job or enter the labor force... There will be mass protests and upheavals everywhere if something doesn't happen.
- doener 9y agoWhy is this article flagged?