2 ms·
The key word is: informally Formal peer review seems to encourage collective backscratching and discourage new ideas (even though some places do anonymous PR,
by raverbashing 9y ago
The key word is: informally
Formal peer review seems to encourage collective backscratching and discourage new ideas (even though some places do anonymous PR, it's not hard to guess where it's coming from if you're a specialist on the area and familiar with the most prominent labs)
- montecarl 9y agoI can confirm that it is very easy to determine who your anonymous reviewers are in specialist areas. In one topic that I used to publish in, I could easily identify one or two of the three reviewers. The main tells are when the reviewer brings up their tangentially related niche interests (e.g. how does this compare to method X or have you considered the effects of <relatively obscure phenomenon>).
- kobeya 9y agoAlso in some cases (e.g. many conferences) you can know who the list of reviewers are. Just look up the program committee. Only a subset reviews your paper submission, but with the field of possible reviewers constrained to 10-12 people you personally know, it becomes very hard to hide.