3 ms·
Would you say that Social Security has a monopoly on retirement saving, or HUD has a monopoly on housing?
by mikeash 9y ago
Would you say that Social Security has a monopoly on retirement saving, or HUD has a monopoly on housing?
- tyingq 9y agoYou get social security benefits back, regardless. It would be comparable if you took away my benefits once I opted for a 401k. I guess it's somewhat comparable to those that use NHS for most things, but supplement with private. But social security isn't enough to retire on for most, so "marketshare" isn't dominant. It sounds like NHS is enough for most healthcare needs. HUD would be comparable, if almost everyone qualified for it. They don't. A monopoly implies dominant marketshare.
- mikeash 9y agoWhy would SS need to take away your benefits to be comparable? It’s not like government health systems kick you out if you ever go to a private hospital.
- tyingq 9y agoPoor analogy on my part. They are different in that Social Security doesn't provide for most retirement needs. Therefore, it doesn't dominate the market. And, so people from many income brackets choose other forms of retirement to supplement. I suspect only a very few supplement NHS since it's comprehensive. That market dominance makes it a monopoly. Edit: I disagree with the conclusion below. A compulsory deduction that's large enough to address all your needs for a particular service creates a monopoly. The issue just seems to be that the word sounds "bad" to those that like the NHS system. If social security deducted enough that it resulted in a reasonable living retirement plan, it would be similar. It would make any other activity in the retirement market very narrow and mostly for rich people.
- mikeash 9y agoSeems like that also makes your original question irrelevant: if what matters is market dominance, then it doesn't matter whether your taxes are reduced if you opt out. In any case, it seems to me that the important thing about a monopoly is most people having no choice. Standard Oil was a monopoly because most people had no choice but to buy their oil from that company. AT&T was a monopoly because that was the only company you could get phone service from. Market dominance is a cause of this key thing, not the key thing itself. A company might have a "monopoly" with 80% of the market because the nature of that market means that 20% isn't enough to provide most customers with a choice. On the other hand, a company might not have a "monopoly" with 95% of the market in a market where scale is less important and 5% of the market is enough to give every customer a choice, and customers choose the dominant player because they want it. Seems to me that the situation with health care in places like the UK is in that second category. The government system is dominant not because people have no choice, but because people don't want to pay for private care.