8 ms·
The Science Behind “Blade Runner”’s Voight-Kampff Test
- DonbunEf7 9y ago"As a psychologist, I am very interested in the question of how we know whether we are seeing reality or not. Everything we know about the world is based, to some extent, on these very crude sensations, so we always have to be epistemically vigilant. Don’t believe what you see." Finally, somebody gets it.
- trendia 9y ago"By Kant's account, when one employs a concept to describe or categorize noumena (the objects of inquiry, investigation or analysis of the workings of the world), one is employing a way of describing or categorizing phenomena (the observable manifestations of those objects of inquiry, investigation or analysis)." Kant 1781 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noumenon#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noumenon#Overview
- pmoriarty 9y agoThe ancient Hindus were talking about the illusory nature of what we perceive around us, and the reality underlying this illusion thousands of years before Kant lived.
- kleer001 9y agoSure, but the probability we're hallucinating goes down quite a bit when all (or most) of our 5+ senses agree that a thing is really there and happening. If it weren't we wouldn't have lasted long in the real world.
- pilooch 9y agoLet's minimize the loss
- tpeo 9y agoArgument from redundancy? Nice.
- QAPereo 9y agoHallucinations are the addition of something which isn’t there, we work more by heavy filtering. We see a narrow slice of EM radiation, what we see is at best, only part of what is real. That doesn’t imply magic, but it does about the incompleteness of our senses.
- kleer001 9y agoThere's also distortions that can mess up our evaluations of the world. We've got some majorly flawed equipment, but it still seems to work just enough so enough of us can reproduce.
- coldtea 9y agoThat presupposes what it's supposed to prove.
- Santosh83 9y agoReality is a loaded word, and I suspect it is a graduated spectrum rather than a single point. What one sees as the 'reality' very much depends on how deeply one can probe and the associated limits in observation.
- freshhawk 9y agoFinally? Somebody? In philosophy this is about as normal a statement as "always check your return values" is in programming.
- CalChris 9y agoNo, the jury concerning the character in 1982’s Blade Runner is NOT still out. Deckard is a replicant. The article gets that wrong and director Ridley Scott himself even explains it: http://www.digitalspy.com/movies/blade-runner/news/a616639/is-blade-runners-deckard-a-replicant-ridley-scotts-definitive-answer/#~oYOhQbdmEOioE2 http://www.digitalspy.com/movies/blade-runner/news/a616639/i... I’ve seen Blade Runner maybe 10 times. I saw it again Tuesday night, in digital projection for the first time, at the Grand Lake in Oakland. Wow. Beautiful.
- mlevental 9y agoyou realize there are more people that contributed to the construction of that universe than just Scott right? (at the least Philip k dick) and none of them have come out agreeing with him, let alone that if it's not substantiated by the source material then it doesn't matter what anyone says (and indeed the are no clear indicators in either of the films that deckerd is a replica the)
- coldtea 9y agoThat's irrelevant since we're talking about Blade Runner the film.
- CalChris 9y agoYou realize the article specifically cited the 1982 movie by Ridley Scott, right? It's most definitely substantiated in that movie, as Scott pointed out. He set the whole movie up for the final unicorn scene.
- ridleywat 9y agoyeah it’s a real shame he misunderstood the source material so blatantly. made it clearer to me why i’ve found the movie dissatisfying, at least
- auggierose 9y agoHow about he didn't misunderstand it, but took it as an inspiration, and created a vision of his own. You don't seem to be a creator.
- solidsnack9000 9y agoI once had a very strange conversation with a Lacanian psychoanalyst, the sort of person I don’t normally interact with. We were talking about whether machines could be conscious. He got very cross and said, “No, of course they can’t,” and I said, “Why not?” He said, “Because they don’t have a mother.” This is almost what I’m beginning to think might be an interesting point. I tried to find some references for this but I am not having much luck so far. People are social animals, and respond to isolation poorly, so maybe there we find at least the beginnings of the idea, that people are only fully people in society. And entry to society more or less demands an upbringing...
- icebraining 9y agoWhy can't machines have an upbringing? HAL: I am a HAL 9000 computer. My instructor was Mr. Langley, and he taught me to sing a song. If you'd like to hear it, I could sing it for you.
- solidsnack9000 9y agoI am not advancing this point of view, just looking for some things to read about it.
- mjburgess 9y agoI really don't know why you're getting down-voted. Modern research child development pegs development of self-conscious to the way we are raised. We are born "pure animals" only feeling, and develop a self-image and awareness-that we are feeling through interaction with others, in particular the care-giver (.../mother). It is by observing others in our animalistic state, reacting to us, that we develop our capacity for self-reflection -- which still isn't fully there at 4 / 5 years old. To put this point most generously: self-consciousness describes a biosocial process by which animals acquire a recognition of themselves as conscious. The claim is then a machine (an oscillating electric field) does not, nor cannot, participate in biosocial processes. NB. If you redefine consciousness to "seeming as-if conscious" then anything may be trivially true of a machine (or, of anything).
- rl3 9y agoOne of my major life regrets is noticing a half-read copy of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? in my optometrist's bag and not cracking a joke about the Voight-Kampff Test prior to him administering an eye exam.
- gjtorikian 9y agoIf that’s a major life regret you must have a pretty nice life.
- rl3 9y agoNah, it's just that I've already made peace with the usual things like wasted career and family prospects. I will however continue to regret not cracking that joke until the day I die.
- cmsefton 9y agoAs pointed out, Scott has said before e.g. in a documentary written and hosted by film critic Mark Kermode called On the Edge of Blade Runner that he meant for Deckard to be a replicant. Harrison Ford never believed he was a replicant, and Rutger Hauer claimed the debate came up after the fact. However, Mark Kermode recently revealed a debate between Scott and the director of the new film, Denis Villeneuve, where Scott repeated this claim, saying that if Deckard wasn't an android, the film wouldn't make any sense: the unicorn, the dream - the central twist is that Deckard doesn't realise that he is a replicant, and that he is chasing himself. Villeneuve however, disputed this, and said that it's not as clear cut as Scott makes out, and that the film is much more ambivalent than that. http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/markkermode/entries/7070baee-ad33-4024-868e-019939dd2c9b http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/markkermode/entries/7070baee-ad33...
- moomin 9y agoIt's pretty clear cut. It just doesn't batter you around the head with it the way the Sixth Sense does. One of my favourite details: there are only five* "healthy human specimens" in the entire movie. Everyone else is fat, old, scarred, suffering from a degenerative disease. Deckard would probably notice this if he had any friends. Instead, he stays home and drinks surrounded by photographs. *Cue a crack about Brion James
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]