3 ms·
Propublica does seem to have an axe to grind with them, it would have been more effective if Propublica compared the Red Cross response with the response of any
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Propublica does seem to have an axe to grind with them, it would have been more effective if Propublica compared the Red Cross response with the response of any other charitable relief agency. Except if they had done so they would have exposed that no other agency. So far I have been unable to find any agency other than FEMA that did more than the Red Cross did for the people of Texas in this emergency.
- falcolas 9y agoLike local food banks, and charity organizations who helped fund them? I imagine if you looked, you would find a dozen, a hundred smaller groups who did a lot more work with a lot less visibility.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoSort of, there are some organizations that did a lot in their local community. There was a school for example that sheltered and fed a bunch of people. They benefit of course from already being there and having a building already that they have access too. This isn't a criticism it is an observation. In terms of other organizations that weren't FEMA that helped more people in Texas during Harvey? My point being to separate evaluation of specific anecdotes over how many total people were helped. And so far from the sources I've been able to look at (granted I'm not in Texas so it limits that) it seems that the Red Cross helped (and is helping) a lot of people. Since the Bay Area will, at some point, be the center of a major natural disaster when it has its 'big' earthquake. I'm trying to understand what helps and what hinders emergency response and aid response. We have had several examples now of Hurricanes so lots of input. And the government tried something new which was pre-deploying material and that was pretty successful. It would be more difficult for the red cross to 'pre-deploy' in part because they get donations generally after or during an event rather than before but there are certainly some things they might be able to do. Rather than try to make people mad at them when they were (as best as I can tell) the most effective aid organization after the Federal Government, how can they be even more effective than they are.