2 ms·
> The image in the article shows nothing of the kind, You are right in that the comparison was only between the group of three layouts in a row. From the image
by weinzierl 9y ago
> The image in the article shows nothing of the kind,
You are right in that the comparison was only between the group of three layouts in a row. From the image no conclusion about the performance of the layouts in different rows can be drawn.
However, in the same study, they did a direct comparison between the grid and and the circular layouts and here are the numbers:
KEYING TIME PER CENT
(SECONDS) ERRORS
THREE-BY-THREE PLUS ONE 6.01 2.5
TELEPHONE 5.90 2.0
SPEEDOMETER 5.97 3.0
The study concludes that the differences are not significant. So my point still stands: The grid was not chosen because of superiority in the human factors study but because, in the words of the study: "the rectangular arrangements [..] offered certain engineering advantages".