5 ms·
Aluminium isn’t the first material I think of for cars, certainly not for ones built in Germany shortly after World War Two. Because of that, I wonder whether
by Someone 9y ago
Aluminium isn’t the first material I think of for cars, certainly not for ones built in Germany shortly after World War Two.
Because of that, I wonder whether this is a one-of (google gives me https://www.lanemotormuseum.org/collection/cars/item/hoffmann-1951 https://www.lanemotormuseum.org/collection/cars/item/hoffman..., which agrees with that) and that coachwork is recycled from an airplane, just as the front axle seems to be recycled from a kubelwagen (https://ww2db.com/vehicle_spec.php?q=359 https://ww2db.com/vehicle_spec.php?q=359)
- tyingq 9y agoThe Ford F150 truck is now aluminum. Somewhat notable since it's their best selling vehicle...not just best selling truck. There's still a fair amount of debate on whether it was a good idea to move to aluminum.
- megaman22 9y agoThe new ones crumple like a coke can if you touch them against anything. I'm not a fan, as expensive as bodywork is these days, and with how much more irritating aluminum is to work with for your average shade-tree mechanic.
- tyingq 9y agoIt did cut about 700lbs off the vehicle, which (in part) took them from 17/23 mpg in 2014 to 19/26 mpg today. I can see the dilemma they have trying to keep up with CAFE standards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_Average_Fuel_Economy#Agreed_standards_by_model_year.2C_2011-2025 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_Average_Fuel_Economy...
- toomanybeersies 9y agoI couple of years ago, I crashed an old Datsun/Nissan truck into a dirt bank going about 30-40 km/h (20-30 mph). It had some damage, but nothing that couldn't be straightened out with a crowbar, and it did need a new radiator. Try that with a modern car, and it would've been totaled, or at least cost a small fortune to get fixed. Upon saying that, if I crashed the truck going 100 km/g (60 mph), I would have probably died. So even though more modern cars don't stand up to low speed crashes so well, they reduce fatalities a lot.
- flachsechs 9y agonearly everything people find 'wrong' with modern cars is done for passenger and pedestrian safety. even the phone integration and annoyingly bad electronic gadgets and infotainment software are designed to get you to put down your phone when driving, or be more aware of your surroundings. remember, the alternative is nearly everyone staring at their phones while driving, and the obvious fallout from that (people still do it, of course, hence the physical safety features). this is the reality that car designers must deal with and a point that is totally lost on the majority of people who complain about 'new cars'. if they could sell you a 1200 pound tin can death-trap with insufficient power and torque, they would, and we'd buy it, because it gets 120mpg and costs $5000.
- Retric 9y agoActual bumpers are not a safety issue. Car companies simply make more money by selling body panels at high markup after every minor accident.
- flachsechs 9y agofor you to say something like "bumpers aren't a safety issue" pretty much discredits you immediately, but i'll answer anyway, for posterity. "actual bumpers" are quite likely the single most extensively regulated pedestrian- and collision-related safety part. there's extensive legislation about their design and characteristics. car companies exist to make money, yes, but they operate within a global framework of strict regulation.
- Retric 9y agoFeel free to look for an actual regulation that prevents ridged bumpers with shock absorbers. You will not find it and in fact many vehicles are sold that can have a 5MPH collision without significant harm. The reasons for this is people can walk into solid objects at 5MPH without significant harm. PS: Feel free to start with: 49 CFR Part 58
- jacquesm 9y agoThey were crap in steel, I would be very surprised if they are any better in aluminum. I had one of these while I lived in Canada (longbox, 3 seater cab) and before the warranty ran out the support strut of the gearbox and the associated welds gave out. Ford refused to fix it because the vehicle was not rated 'heavy duty'. The heaviest we ever hauled in it was a load of firewood. Welding aluminum properly is a lot harder than welding steel and aluminum is also a lot less forgiving than steel when it comes to constructing cars out of it. I never bought a Ford after that wonderful, and I'm still amazed that they would not stand behind their product, good luck to anybody that buys an F150 made of aluminum.
- unclepresent 9y agoweight is probably a driving factor. When you save 100-150 pounds of weight by using some aluminium parts you can use this weight elsewhere. Not sure I am right. Just thinking.
- tyingq 9y agoFord cut 700lbs off the F150 by going to aluminum. Not to use it elsewhere, but to improve fuel economy.
- d-sc 9y agoAs long as we’re getting into anecdotal evidence. I’ve driven an F150 as a personal vehicle and ran it pretty heavily(80 MPH over steep passes, firewood hauling, heavy trailers, off-road on farm, etc) and haven’t had any problems. I’ve also used ford’s heavy duty trucks in construction and haven’t had problems. It’s important to remember that Ford is a large company and with enough vechicles you are bound to have cases where they don’t meet standards. Without a statistically significant dataset it’s hard to make a judgement whether one manufacturer is more reliable than another.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agox2. My anecdotal evidence is that 0% of the vehicle I have beat the living shit out of have been trouble prone in any way.
- bluedino 9y agoThe F150 has been aluminum for three years, and the body of the F250 is now also made of aluminum.
- Animats 9y agoThe classic F250 was very solidly built. I have a 1985 Ford Bronco, which is an F250 chassis with a different body and was built to comply with the 5MPH bumper standard in effect for a few years. It was once rear-ended while stopped by a SamTrans passenger van. The SamTrans van front end crumpled properly, leaving its nose on the pavement. The Bronco had a bent trailer connector and a broken license plate lamp housing. 12MPG, though.
- digi_owl 9y agoAnd they even had to add weights in strategic locations to give the impression it still had a steel frame...
- usrusr 9y agoAll the aluminium from discarded aircraft (and there were a lot more than Luftwaffe could fuel or staff) had to go somewhere... E.g. many bicycles built in the 1950ies had aluminium rims, which would a few years later disappear from the market except for the most high end racing bikes, not to make a mainstream comeback for decades. For a while, even kitchen utensils were hard to get in anything but aluminium. The recycling economy that was developed in wartime scarcity was never completely abandoned in later years.
- mcguire 9y agoThat's how Alumacraft got started in the US.
- burger_moon 9y agoDuring World War II there was a shortage of copper in the US so generators were wound with aluminum instead because it was more plentiful. Perhaps it's a similar thing with steel vs aluminum availability.
- walshemj 9y agoIt parts of the uk the last mile of phone lines was done in AL when copper was really expensive. Milton Keyes famously has this of course this means that ADSL didn't work Edited to change AU to AL
- falsedan 9y agoIf I had gold wires I sure as heck would rip them out, darn the DSL signal.
- walshemj 9y agooops a senior moment there AL not AU
- digi_owl 9y agoI have heard of train lines getting switched because the copper ones would constantly get stolen...
- walshemj 9y agothe wiring beside the tracks absolutely you quite often get delays due to some one trying to rip out coper - the dumb criminals try and rip fibre out
- digi_owl 9y agoYeah i recall reading about some eastern European nation that lost their net connection for some time because some elderly lady dug up their fiber while looking for copper.