3 ms·
Victim blaming? These people aren't victims. They're people who picked a profession where it is (and always has been) difficult to find success, both in terms
by kelnos 9y ago
Victim blaming? These people aren't victims. They're people who picked a profession where it is (and always has been) difficult to find success, both in terms of popularity and material wealth.
I don't see the creator's job as worthless, but I do think I see it as more of a commodity than many creators would like. The biggest hits in music today aren't there because they're somehow objectively the best at their craft. Don't get me wrong, they do have talent, but their success is largely driven by promotion and marketing. There are a ton of largely-unknown artists who could see just as much success if only they'd been able to get their material in front of someone with influence and reach in a better way than the current incumbent successes have done.
> On a more general note, when a vulnerable part of the population gets shafted, they shouldn't "get with the times" either. It's a sign of our failure as a society.
I'm very sympathetic toward people who are actually in vulnerable places. People who can't kick drug addictions, people who are homeless, people who just made one bad decision or just had enough bad luck to end up in a bad place. Creative types are not that. They've chosen to follow their passions to the place they are now. Even older artists simply can't remember a time when their craft was a "gold mine", because that's never been the case.
> I guess it is not surprising that people in a capitalistic society think that the value of an activity lies in how much profit it can generate to the performer of that activity.
I think you give people too little credit. I think people understand that an activity can be very valuable to society but not be lucrative at all. Grade-school teachers are the prototype example of this that pretty much everyone has heard before.
I don't think many people would argue that music and art have low value to society. They're certainly not essentials like housing, clothing, and food. They're not going to push the sum of human understanding further like scientific research. But they're certainly more valuable than some bullshit apps that we talk about here, things like "Yo" that attracted an obscene amount of investment for what I'd consider very little value.
But I feel like you contradict yourself with this point you've made. If you do manage to separate the value of an activity from the profit generated for the performers, you can easily make the argument that no one "deserves" to get paid for creative output. Just because something has non-monetary value, it doesn't mean people will want to pay a lot for it.