3 ms·
"He also said that these stars [that “have not really earned their status”] have boasted to him that they almost never send their articles to “anywhere but Natu
by mcguire 9y ago
"He also said that these stars [that “have not really earned their status”] have boasted to him that they almost never send their articles to “anywhere but Nature, Cell, or Science“—among the three most prestigious science journals. “And they are nearly always published in one of those magazines—where, when you see something you know about, you realize that it’s not always so great,” he continued."
I subscribed to Science for a while (the only benefit I can see of AAAS membership), and I was surprised by the work published there. I'm a computer jockey, and not into the biology that Science mostly publishes, but I had expected it to be major, ground-breaking papers. Instead, it seemed like the same kind of minimum publishable unit that goes on everywhere.
- Amygaz 9y agoIt's mostly about clicks now! If they think your story or your PI's name will drive traffic then it gets accepted. There are still a few very well done top notch paper that gets there, and some other half-backed but very creative which have some merit to be there. But even these have the "driving ads" as their first criteria.
- evolve2017 9y agoI think it’s unfair to discounts papers in a foreign field to one’s own as ‘minimum publishable unit’ - often the novelty and importance of a finding requires some background, which the new, longer narrative abstracts in Science are trying to provide.
- mcguire 9y agoTrue, I'm out on a limb here. But the "news" part of Science is very good, and has insightful coverage of science activities. In comparison with the rest of the magazine, the published research in Science was...meh.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PurpleRamen 9y agoScience today is like playing an RPG. You constantly solve quest which other players have solved already before you. But because you need the XP, you need to do it to reach a higher level, to play in the good league where all the good stuff drops.
- idiot900 9y agoI am a biologist, and while not everything these journals publish is super-compelling, by and large most of it is stuff that changes the way we think about particular scientific questions. The standard is definitely well above "minimum publishable unit".
- Fomite 9y agoIt should be noted that many of the papers in Science are essentially summaries of larger, longer bodies of papers in other journals. It’s especially easy, especially if you’re outside the field, to think these are trivial. What they’re actually meant to be is accessible to you.