3 ms·
> You need to be careful because it's hard to define what shaming and ostracism mean. I don't think it is. In any case, I am not trying to write a law so a sol
by shkkmo 9y ago
> You need to be careful because it's hard to define what shaming and ostracism mean.
I don't think it is. In any case, I am not trying to write a law so a solid definition is not necessary.
> I think James Watson is a both misogynist and racist and I don't want to be part of a meeting where he is involved.
James Watson was fired the way he was, not because of his words, but because of the internet's reaction to his words and Google's desire to get ahead of the news cycle. I suspect he will win or settle his court case against Google.
I don't know James Watson, you may be right. Do you know him? Have you talked to him? How do you know meetings with him involved would be bad?
I definitely think we would be better served if people have focused on picking apart his mis-used scientific terms, mistaken understanding of some experiments and rather incoherent argument. Instead people decided to loudly label him as sexist, push google into firing him, and push him straight into the waiting arms of the alt-right.
> Am I shaming or ostracizing him, or am I practicing my rights of free speech and association?
Both.
> To be fair, "reason, discussion and facts" have always been malleable in the hands of the powerful. "The Divine Right of Kings" was based on them. So was "scientific racism".
I fail to get your point... other than you think reason is useless?
> In general, by what reason and what facts do you determine that my actions are no longer acceptable? If that happens, what can you do about it which won't, in turn, be labeled "shaming, ostracizing, and censoring"?
When you violate the law, we will prosecute you and send you to prison. If you violate our organization's policy, we will discipline or fire you. If you say mean things to our other guests and show no remorse, we won't invite you to our house. If you tell me you think the holocaust didn't happen I will attempt to use reason and facts to discuss it with you.
- eesmith 9y ago"James Watson was fired the way he was" Umm, pardon? I'm talking about the Nobel prize winner. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Watson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Watson . I think you're thinking of James Damore? What sort of meetings do you think I would go to where Damore might speak? "How do you know meetings with him involved would be bad?" Watson's record is quite well documented. Some of them are: http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=119772&page=1 http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=119772&page=1 , https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn12835-james-watson-retires-amidst-race-controversy/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn12835-james-watson-re... and https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/fury-at-dna-pioneers-theory-africans-are-less-intelligent-than-westerners-394898.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/fury-at-dna-pione... Or for a personal report, at https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2017/05/29/jim-watson-needs-to-retire-to-a-nice-remote-beach-somewhere-far-from-everyone-else/ https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2017/05/29/jim-watso... : > I had dinner with Watson at a small restaurant in New York several years ago. It was the most uncomfortable two hours of my life. All he wanted to talk about was race, and the conversation was all about our geneaology. He asked what my ancestry was, and when I told him half Scandinavian, half Scot/English/Irish he immediately judged me acceptable company, and started explaining my personality to me. Scandinavians are intelligent but cold and aloof, and share the same problems that the Japanese have: they are among the smartest people in the world, but they lack the passion and drive to accomplish great things. You know who may not be as intrinsically intelligent, but make up for it with their aggressive need to get things done? The Scots/Irish! Best people on the planet! The perfect combination of ambition and smarts! ... “So, Jim, what’s your ancestry?” “Scots/Irish!” he cackled. His unfounded statements caused many others to avoid him ("ostricize" in your terms) so he missed out on speaking fees. In order to maintain his life style (which included buying some fancy artwork), he sold his Nobel Prize. http://www.smh.com.au/technology/sci-tech/james-watson-the-father-of-dna-is-selling-his-nobel-prize-because-everyone-thinks-hes-racist-20141201-11y1f4.html http://www.smh.com.au/technology/sci-tech/james-watson-the-f... . Someone bought it $4.1 million and gave it back to him. You wrote "I fail to get your point... other than you think reason is useless?" I said they were malleable. I didn't say useless. Facts are interpreted in a framework. Who gets to decide the framework? It's usually those in power who pay for the scientists, and for "the facts", and that influences how those facts are discussed. Quoting https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/10/a-brief-history-of-everyone-who-ever-lived/537942/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/10/a-brief-... on the controversy concerning Kennewick Man, "We sometimes forget that though the data should be pure and straightforward, science is done by people, who are never either."