5 ms·
Hate to tell him, but welcome to the real world. This is not a problem specific to academia! Stars not having really earned their status? This is true in all i
by ryandrake 9y ago
Hate to tell him, but welcome to the real world. This is not a problem specific to academia!
Stars not having really earned their status? This is true in all institutions, businesses, governments, schools, home owners associations, book clubs, sewing circles, etc. Any group of people where "resources" are allocated by a human, there will be people who earn their status and there will be people who instead focus on influencing the allocators. Strange to have to tell grown-ups this.
- jknoepfler 9y agoI don't think Hall "needs to be told" anything. The people who lost out here aren't Hall and the academics who can't get funding. Hall is doing fine in the private sector. The people who lose in this situation are the public, who no longer own the research output, and who no longer benefit from the long-term gains made by primary research. We should create, for ourselves, a sustainable research economy. We've failed to do that. Are you suggesting it's impossible because you think "reality isn't fair" or "people suck"? I don't think the latter entails the former.
- pdfernhout 9y agoFrom the conclusion of this 1994 paper: https://www.its.caltech.edu/~dg/crunch_art.html https://www.its.caltech.edu/~dg/crunch_art.html "Let me finish by summarizing what I've been trying to tell you. We stand at an historic juncture in the history of science. The long era of exponential expansion ended decades ago, but we have not yet reconciled ourselves to that fact. The present social structure of science, by which I mean institutions, education, funding, publications and so on all evolved during the period of exponential expansion, before The Big Crunch. They are not suited to the unknown future we face. Today's scientific leaders, in the universities, government, industry and the scientific societies are mostly people who came of age during the golden era, 1950 - 1970. I am myself part of that generation. We think those were normal times and expect them to return. But we are wrong. Nothing like it will ever happen again. It is by no means certain that science will even survive, much less flourish, in the difficult times we face. Before it can survive, those of us who have gained so much from the era of scientific elites and scientific illiterates must learn to face reality, and admit that those days are gone forever. I think we have our work cut out for us."
- cowsandmilk 9y ago> Hall is doing fine in the private sector. He moved into the woods of Maine to a town w/ a population less than 500. He is doing fine, but he isn't in the private sector. Losing funding meant "he's retired with dwindling coffers"[1]. [1] https://www.usatoday.com/videos/news/nation/2017/10/03/jeffrey-c.-hall-says-nobel-prize-unexpected/106251992/ https://www.usatoday.com/videos/news/nation/2017/10/03/jeffr...
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoI agree that there are parallels of this phenomena in other fields. It’s part of human nature. The people good at self marketing procure more resources even if they are technically worse.
- randomsearch 9y agoDon't you think you should design a better system where this doesn't happen, or perhaps occurs less frequently? For example, stop simply awarding grants based on proposals, and instead spread the money more evenly - reducing grant-writing overhead and giving everyone funding to at least _do something_.
- mattkrause 9y agoIt is though... He's not arguing that stars shouldn't exist; he's arguing that funding decisions should be less influenced by "star power" and there are policy tweaks that could help achieve that. It's worth noting that at the NIH (etc), you don't really know who "the allocators" are. Program managers make the final funding decisions, but they rely heavily on peer review and you don't know who in the study section will be reviewing your proposal. Changing this so they don't know the proposer's identities either might help.