6 ms·
"Free Speech" is a valuable trait of a society. Government restrictions on that speech were (and still are) the largest threat to that freedom when the bill of
by shkkmo 9y ago
"Free Speech" is a valuable trait of a society. Government restrictions on that speech were (and still are) the largest threat to that freedom when the bill of rights was written.
We have reached a point where government is not the only entity with the power to severely restrict the freedom of speech in our society.
Is the solution to this to pass a new law or make a new amendment curtailing freedom of associated? I personally don't think we have the political capability to write that law well, (even if it wasn't a horrible idea.)
But that doesn't mean we should should pushing, encouraging and shaming these private entities into doing MORE censorship and doing our best as private entities to limit the freedom of speech that exists in our society.
- eesmith 9y agoStrong anti-monopoly laws which break up Google and Facebook would solve the problem, yes? Without touching the freedom of assembly or speech. I'm not saying it's the best solution, but bring it up to point out that it's important to also consider the economics which caused the problem to arise in the first place. Remember, unrestrained capitalism doesn't incorporate human rights - as the slave trade shows.
- shkkmo 9y ago> Strong anti-monopoly laws which break up Google and Facebook would solve the problem, yes? While we do strongly need a revamp of our anti-monopoly laws, I don't think that really solves the problem. The core problem as I see it is that people's goto approach for combating objectionable ideas is veering towards shaming, ostracizing, and censoring rather than reason, discussion and facts.
- eradicatethots 9y agoIt’s not really practical to combat ideas with reason, after a while.
- shkkmo 9y agoI vehemently disagree. If you abandon reason, then you can only be right by pure coincidence. If you vanquish ideas using means other than reason, then you have only vanquished bad ideas by pure coincidence.
- s73ver_ 9y agoAnd I disagree with that. Having to decry ever racist that pops up on Twitter with "reason" when they had no intention of debating in good faith in the first place is exhausting. And quite frankly, letting them run wild just means that other people are going to stop going there and contributing to the discourse. So now all you've done is succeeded in silencing marginalized people, which was their goal in the first place.
- shkkmo 9y ago> Having to decry ever racist that pops up on Twitter with "reason" when they had no intention of debating in good faith in the first place is exhausting That sounds exhausting. Maybe you should pick a couple of the ones that do appear to be interested in debating in good faith? > letting them run wild just means that other people are going to stop going there and contributing to the discourse. So now all you've done is succeeded in silencing marginalized people, which was their goal in the first place. And the alternative is to ban everything from twitter that people find offensive? I think that is a losing proposition. I'd much rather focus on promoting and spreading content from silenced and marginalized people to make sure their voices are heard and amplified.
- eesmith 9y agoSome trolls specialize in sealioning. It's hard to tell which ones are debating in good faith. Plus, assuming most are not debating in good faith then that still leaves us with the problem that the "other people are going to stop going there and contributing to the discourse". Perhaps you can share from your experience in decrying racists on Twitter how you can distinguish one from the other? "And the alternative is to ban everything from twitter that people find offensive" Is banning from above the only solution you can think of? One alternative is much more effective control tools. Some people voluntarily use collaboratively developed blacklists of accounts to ignore. This is not censorship any more than kicking someone unruly out of your meeting in a library meeting room is censorship. (Old-style shared Usenet killfiles are also not censorship.) Combine that with some collaboratively developed training corpus of spam/ham to filter your twitter stream. Then have Twitter set up a few default filters, rather like "Safe Search" on Google. Very few people say that GMail censors their email by automatically placing some messages into "Junk". However, this will cost money, and likely not increase Twitter revenue. It might even decrease it. So why would they do it?
- eesmith 9y agoTo be fair, "reason, discussion and facts" have always been malleable in the hands of the powerful. "The Divine Right of Kings" was based on them. So was "scientific racism". You need to be careful because it's hard to define what shaming and ostracism mean. I think James Watson is a both misogynist and racist and I don't want to be part of a meeting where he is involved. Am I shaming or ostracizing him, or am I practicing my rights of free speech and association? In general, by what reason and what facts do you determine that my actions are no longer acceptable? If that happens, what can you do about it which won't, in turn, be labeled "shaming, ostracizing, and censoring"?
- shkkmo 9y ago> You need to be careful because it's hard to define what shaming and ostracism mean. I don't think it is. In any case, I am not trying to write a law so a solid definition is not necessary. > I think James Watson is a both misogynist and racist and I don't want to be part of a meeting where he is involved. James Watson was fired the way he was, not because of his words, but because of the internet's reaction to his words and Google's desire to get ahead of the news cycle. I suspect he will win or settle his court case against Google. I don't know James Watson, you may be right. Do you know him? Have you talked to him? How do you know meetings with him involved would be bad? I definitely think we would be better served if people have focused on picking apart his mis-used scientific terms, mistaken understanding of some experiments and rather incoherent argument. Instead people decided to loudly label him as sexist, push google into firing him, and push him straight into the waiting arms of the alt-right. > Am I shaming or ostracizing him, or am I practicing my rights of free speech and association? Both. > To be fair, "reason, discussion and facts" have always been malleable in the hands of the powerful. "The Divine Right of Kings" was based on them. So was "scientific racism". I fail to get your point... other than you think reason is useless? > In general, by what reason and what facts do you determine that my actions are no longer acceptable? If that happens, what can you do about it which won't, in turn, be labeled "shaming, ostracizing, and censoring"? When you violate the law, we will prosecute you and send you to prison. If you violate our organization's policy, we will discipline or fire you. If you say mean things to our other guests and show no remorse, we won't invite you to our house. If you tell me you think the holocaust didn't happen I will attempt to use reason and facts to discuss it with you.