3 ms·
> Imagine our society passes laws to ban the publishing of abhorrent and bigoted ideas. No longer are people allowed to express racism, sexism, homophobia, or a
by geofft 9y ago
> Imagine our society passes laws to ban the publishing of abhorrent and bigoted ideas. No longer are people allowed to express racism, sexism, homophobia, or antisemitism. So we ban Mein Kampf.
Is this an actual proposal?
Most things I have seen in the discourse that seem to be objected to on free speech grounds are e.g. proposals to prevent certain speakers from speaking at colleges, proposals to prevent certain groups from having marches, proposals for certain discussion websites to ban particularly toxic/abusive users, etc.
This seems to me to be very different from banning Mein Kampf as a book. I think you can coherently believe in the above bans while also believing that Mein Kampf should be available on Project Gutenberg etc. for anyone to read and evaluate, for people to understand what is this scary book that people keep talking about, etc.
To take the example of banning speakers at colleges - I don't think any one of the people for whom no-platforming has been proposed lacks a platform of their own. They have websites. They have books. Their ideas are out there. If their ideas are in fact coherent enough for "the opportunity of exchanging error for truth," that debate can already happen.
If they aren't, the virtue-signaling approach of putting up "ideological minorities" in college lecture halls to say the exact same thing they've said 100 times before isn't going to help anyone reach truth.