4 ms·
> You misunderstand me. I thought it was clear that I was talking about ideas, not threats or inciting mobs. And who decides what's an "idea" and what's "threa
by geofft 9y ago
> You misunderstand me. I thought it was clear that I was talking about ideas, not threats or inciting mobs.
And who decides what's an "idea" and what's "threats or inciting mobs"?
Would you be happy for the British government to say that of course the colonists have the right to free speech, but many of them are advocating threats and inciting mobs, which isn't allowed? Or for the king of Thailand to say the same thing about those who insult the king? Or for the Spanish government to say the same thing about Catalonian politicians? Or for Trump to say this about the women's march?
What is a threat or a mob? Is a group of Nazis in Nazi uniforms marching down the street saying Nazi things somehow not a threat or a mob? The ACLU believes they have a right to free speech!
- s73ver_ 9y agoOh the other hand what about, Milo pushing his followers to send Leslie Jones racist imagery and slurs on Twitter? Is that an idea, or inciting a mob?
- geofft 9y agoYup, exactly. To be clear about my position, I believe that "free speech" is an impractical ideal, and we as a society need to be clear about what sorts of speech we value and what we don't, and if we don't do that, we're left with one of two bad options: either we have to err so hard on the side of free speech that we can't ban threats or incitement to violence or anything at all, or we let the government define "threats" in a way that is prone to government abuse just like everything else is.
- eradicatethots 9y agoAs the OP says, if you ban speech you are marking it as permanently unthinkable.
- s73ver_ 9y agoIn the case of, say, social media platforms banning violent threats against their other users, is that a bad thing?
- geofft 9y agoThat's asserted by the OP, but I don't think that claim is supported by the OP or by his sources. I argue that banning speech (as a speech act) and banning ideas are different things. To pick a sort of pedantic counterexample, banning me from yelling a racial slur at you in public more than once isn't making anything unthinkable. I can yell it once, other people can yell it at you, I can yell it at others, people can record the yell on YouTube, etc. So, I agree with OP's argument that we should not ban ideas, and I do agree that speech is necessary to communicate ideas (of course), but I think that banning some speech acts can be entirely defensible. (Also, remember that every functioning advanced society bans several forms of speech already - a good example is that I am banned from using a trademark without authorization from the trademark holder, or from reproducing copyrighted material, or from making defamatory claims.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]