3 ms·
When we "suppress speech", we aren't actually suppressing the utterance but rather limiting the audience. This may seem like a good way to limit the spread of
by shkkmo 9y ago
When we "suppress speech", we aren't actually suppressing the utterance but rather limiting the audience.
This may seem like a good way to limit the spread of an idea and it will definitely reduce the spread in the short term.
However, people will always find a way to communicate (e.g. side channels and dog whistles develop). This means that eventually you've now only removed from the audience those who are the least susceptible to the idea and have the best tools for refuting it.
At this point, the idea is actually better able to spread within it's audience because dissenting voices have been isolated.
As you broaden the criteria for what is suppressed (used to be use of the N word, now includes mentioning any genetic component to differences in distributions of traits between genders), you end up driving more and more people into this isolated audience and encouraging the spread of very objectionable ideas to people who used to just have mildly objectionable ideas.
The more we allow private companies with monopolistic or oligopolistic products to push these voices out of the mainstream the worse off we will be in the long term as these ideas become more entrenched, isolated and difficult to remove.
The more we rely on shunning, ostracizing and public shaming as tools to battle objectionable ideas, the more we encourage the creation of communities that are fertile ground for those ideas to grow in.
[edit: minor grammar fixes]