7 ms·
I think a common failure (intentional or not) in discussing free speech is isolating free speech absolutism from the sort of free speech that we'd be happy to a
by woodruffw 9y ago
I think a common failure (intentional or not) in discussing free speech is isolating free speech absolutism from the sort of free speech that we'd be happy to accept in a liberal, open society.
Speaking practically and from the absolutist perspective, there should be no legal penalty for inciting others to violence. However, I think that (nearly) all of us recognize the importance of motive in cases -- we rightfully recognize both the inciter and the mob and assign blame commensurately. Most of us, I think, would not want to live in a society where inciting panic or violence is at least morally neutral. If that's the case and we think that the laws should reflect such a judgement, then it follows that open societies must (counterintuitively) place restrictions on free speech.[1]
Geoff makes good points, and he uses good sources to advance those points. But we should not think that Paine or Mill would be comfortable with the absolutist rhetoric that they get applied popularly to today.
[1]: Karl Popper called this the "Paradox of Tolerance."
- ggreer 9y agoYou misunderstand me. I thought it was clear that I was talking about ideas, not threats or inciting mobs. You'll have a hard time finding any self-described free speech absolutist who thinks those should be permitted.
- blowski 9y agoIs it always clear when it’s one or the other? If I say “western society is decadent and as such should be overthrown” is that an idea or an incitement to violence?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ggreer 9y agoIt's usually pretty clear, and if it's not then it's best to err on the side of free speech. Declaring one's desire to overthrow western society is not a threat or an incitement to violence. Here's an example of what counts as free speech in the US: "If they ever make me carry a rifle the first man I want to get in my sights is L. B. J."[1] It has to be a true threat. Likewise, inciting a mob only applies to actual mobs on the verge of violence. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threatening_the_President_of_the_United_States#Watts_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threatening_the_President_of_t...
- michaelt 9y agoIt's usually pretty clear Is it? Seems to me if I wanted to preach hate I'd wrap it in allusions, hypotheticals and you-know-what-I-mean Maybe letting that stuff through is the cost of free speech?
- AndrewBissell 9y agoHe's not saying "it's clear when someone is preaching hate" (it is certainly often couched in oblique language to avoid attracting ire and opposition), he's saying, "it's pretty clear when someone is making a threat or incitement to imminent, actual violence." Neither "The Jews will not replace us" nor "euthanize the rentiers" constitutes an imminent threat of violence.
- geofft 9y ago> You misunderstand me. I thought it was clear that I was talking about ideas, not threats or inciting mobs. And who decides what's an "idea" and what's "threats or inciting mobs"? Would you be happy for the British government to say that of course the colonists have the right to free speech, but many of them are advocating threats and inciting mobs, which isn't allowed? Or for the king of Thailand to say the same thing about those who insult the king? Or for the Spanish government to say the same thing about Catalonian politicians? Or for Trump to say this about the women's march? What is a threat or a mob? Is a group of Nazis in Nazi uniforms marching down the street saying Nazi things somehow not a threat or a mob? The ACLU believes they have a right to free speech!
- s73ver_ 9y agoOh the other hand what about, Milo pushing his followers to send Leslie Jones racist imagery and slurs on Twitter? Is that an idea, or inciting a mob?
- geofft 9y agoYup, exactly. To be clear about my position, I believe that "free speech" is an impractical ideal, and we as a society need to be clear about what sorts of speech we value and what we don't, and if we don't do that, we're left with one of two bad options: either we have to err so hard on the side of free speech that we can't ban threats or incitement to violence or anything at all, or we let the government define "threats" in a way that is prone to government abuse just like everything else is.
- eradicatethots 9y agoAs the OP says, if you ban speech you are marking it as permanently unthinkable.
- s73ver_ 9y agoIn the case of, say, social media platforms banning violent threats against their other users, is that a bad thing?
- jbpetersen 9y agoThere does need to be some sort of sane standard for determining whether something counts as a threat/incitement if they're not going to be permitted. Say I'm very popular on twitter, and say I don't like somebody for whatever reason. If there's a reasonable expectation that this will result in them being mobbed by my less personable followers, does that count as incitement? Or at what point does aggressive banter in good faith become an actual threat in [favorite multiplayer video game]?
- s73ver_ 9y agoI think we're not even at that point, yet. On Twitter, there are lots of people who receive violent threats, and they're told by Twitter that those are not a violation of the ToS.
- woodruffw 9y agoI understood you, but I think that you conflated freedom of conscience with freedom of speech. Freedom of conscience seems pretty uncontroversial, and it's what Paine is talking about in the quote you gave (on my interpretation). I think everybody agrees that freedom of conscience is both good and necessary in an open society. However, it's incorrect to think that absolute freedom of speech necessarily follows. > You'll have a hard time finding any self-described free speech absolutist who thinks those should be permitted. I've debated people who believe this. You and I don't have to agree with them, but they exist.
- AndrewBissell 9y agoHow can anyone be said to have freedom of conscience when the range of thought they may encounter is circumscribed by censors?
- woodruffw 9y agoFirst, the cases I've listed aren't ambitious ones -- there are no censors, only public courts looking at a case after the fact to determine whether someone's speech was indeed inciteful. Second, how can anybody discover facts about the world if they haven't been discovered yet? Truth and thought are not contingent upon prior art; at best, they just speed it up a bit.
- ggreer 9y ago> I understood you I'm sorry but you don't. (Also, don't I get to decide that, not you?) > Freedom of conscience seems pretty uncontroversial, and it's what Paine is talking about in the quote you gave (on my interpretation). Paine and Mill weren't just talking about freedom of conscience or thought. Paine thought it crucial to hear others' ideas so that he could avoid being wrong. That requires the ideas be expressed. Likewise with Mill. Chapter 2 of On Liberty is titled "Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion"[1]. Throughout the text, Mill defends expression as well as thought, and condemns the silencing of any expression of opinion: > But I deny the right of the people to exercise such coercion, either by themselves or by their government. The power itself is illegitimate. The best government has no more title to it than the worst. It is as noxious, or more noxious, when exerted in accordance with public opinion, than when in opposition to it. 1. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/On_Liberty/Chapter_2 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/On_Liberty/Chapter_2
- s73ver_ 9y agoI think you'll find a lot of people who will disagree what constitutes "threats or inciting mobs".
- colanderman 9y agoThough tangential to the points in the article, there's also a common failure to distinguish between freedom from infringement of speech by the government, and freedom from infringement by private parties. The former is guaranteed by the federal government; the latter is not (though some states provide limited protections [1]). Not to mention failure to distinguish exercise of free speech (permitted) from discrimination against protected classes (prohibited). (The old "I'm exercising my right to free speech by refusing to provide gays/blacks/etc. services" argument.) "My rights end where your rights begin" is an important pillar of modern society that really precludes any sort of absolutism about free speech. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Private_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_...
- shkkmo 9y agoBoth government and private parties can pose separate risks to free speech, but the value of freedom of speech in a society does not change based on where those risks are coming from. The point your are making is against the strawman argument that the first amendment should prohibit private companies editorial decisions. I haven't seen anyone making that claim. When the bill of rights was drafted, it was inconceivable that any company would have the level of control over speech that companies have today.
- colanderman 9y agoI can't follow whether you're arguing for or against interpreting the first amendment as prohibiting restriction of speech by private entities. (Your 2nd paragraph seems against, but your 3rd paragraph seems for.) Regardless, I'm not arguing either, I'm stating facts backed by case law as outlined in the linked Wikipedia article to support the thesis that the phrase "free speech" is used to mean many different things, often to deliberately confound discussion on the topic. If supporters of "free speech" clarified what exactly what flavor of "free speech" they are talking about (1st amendment prohibition of federal restrictions; imagined prohibition of private restrictions; ability to override rights of protected classes) I suspect we'd have fewer, and more productive, discussions. Unfortunately such precision of language is hard to come by in this brave new world of emotion-driven discource and deliberately confounded communication.
- rothbardrand 9y agoYou are operating/arguing from the neutral reality perspective-- that is to say, that "we as a society" exists as a concrete entity that can pass laws. But that's not the case. We are not the government, far from it. The government is a collection of people who have power over us. Many of them are corrupt and will do evil-- just imagine the worse member of the political party you disagree with as a dictator. Every time you want to give government power to the government, imagine that guy as a dictator wielding that power. Any limitations, as we have seen, on human rights become the camel nose under the tent, and then you eventually end up with government violating the right wholesale. (eg: secret courts and secret rulings, National Security Letters an the like, illegal surveillance and wiretapping.) While inciting a mob to violence can be considered immoral, it is the violence that is the crime... the action.... not the opinion.
- s73ver_ 9y ago"You are operating/arguing from the neutral reality perspective-- that is to say, that "we as a society" exists as a concrete entity that can pass laws. But that's not the case. We are not the government, far from it. The government is a collection of people who have power over us." That we, the people, choose (a least in non-dictatorship countries). "While inciting a mob to violence can be considered immoral, it is the violence that is the crime... the action.... not the opinion." Taken to extremes, that means that hiring a hit man, or ordering someone in your cult to kill someone isn't responsible. And yet, as a society, we've said otherwise.
- GauntletWizard 9y agoThis argument is patently false. As soon as you give them the power to censor speech, we stop choosing the government - They choose themselves, by deciding what we can and cannot say, who we can and cannot hear from, who gets to even announce their candidacy. See https://youtu.be/c1HdCIW2Xtk https://youtu.be/c1HdCIW2Xtk - We're not China, but they're not even using their official power to censor, just misusing their official power to look the other way while their unofficial power censors. This is why we need adversarial politics - And why even trolls must be protected speech, because they serve as a canary in the coal mine about what you're not allowed to say.
- AndrewBissell 9y ago> Karl Popper called this the "Paradox of Tolerance." Popper was talking about a last resort, not something which should be applied as a blanket policy of suppression of "unacceptable" viewpoints. This gross misreading of Popper's thoughts on free speech was popularized by a cartoon which went flying around social media after Charlottesville. But here's what he actually said on the subject: > I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be unwise.
- woodruffw 9y agoI was familiar with Popper well before Charlottesville, and that footnote only refers to the same paradox, not the same argument. In any case, Sarte seems more applicable to our current rash of "ironic" intolerance: > Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past.
- nickbauman 9y agoPopper is indeed the best articulation of the caveat of the OP. We must be intolerant of intolerance. And intolerance is defined as ideas that attack others based on inalienable aspects (skin color, lineage and the like) or intrinsic to our understanding of self determination that does not impinge on the rights of others (religion, beliefs, sexual orientation and the like).