3 ms·
Not quite. Inflation isn’t the outright awful thing people assume it is. Further, the concept is to give people just enough to survive. That creates demand for
by ianai 9y ago
Not quite. Inflation isn’t the outright awful thing people assume it is. Further, the concept is to give people just enough to survive. That creates demand for only the basics. The basics are largely standardized items. When was the last time there was a shortage in corn, cotton, flour? They’re all commodities. If anything modern prices for these goods and services are likely to be indifferent to the increase in demand from simple basic income.
Another example is the cost of additional real estate outside the city. Building costs in rural America are essentially linear with demand. There’s no shortage of land out there and basic income would allow people to live in such areas.
- hpcjoe 9y agoIts not awful over a short term. Over a longer term, it will price commodities out of reach. I've watched milk prices rise dramatically over the last 5 years or so. This is in part due to the costs of production rising, not necessarily the farm margins. These costs of production rise for any number of reasons, but mostly its because rising costs tend to spread out through the economy. [1] My point is that prices will rise and find their time dependent values, in a way that will diminish the purchasing power of those you'd be attempting to help. You give enough so they have some left over, and enterprising groups will realize that they can raise prices to reflect the larger purchasing power. Economics 101 in this case. [1] http://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0212/inflation-and-economic-recovery.aspx http://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0212/inflation-an...
- SirRhosis 9y agoMilk inflation is not that significant. Five dollars of milk in 2000 will cost you 6.51 USD today[0]. It's actually lower this year than it was in 2014[1]. [0] - http://www.in2013dollars.com/Milk/price-inflation http://www.in2013dollars.com/Milk/price-inflation [1] - https://ycharts.com/indicators/milk_price https://ycharts.com/indicators/milk_price
- ianai 9y agoMilk is also not a necessity for survival. Also over the longer term the UBI would increase at the base inflation rate. It would have to move in relation to all things.
- hpcjoe 9y agoHmm ... not 3 years ago, the milk I currently pay $4/gallon for was selling for ~$3/gallon. Maybe outside of Michigan it is different.
- thebooktocome 9y agoHeh, in Ohio milk is currently 1$/gal.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I've watched milk prices rise dramatically over the last 5 years or so. Milk is subject to government price supports, including a mandate to purchase if market prices fall below a certain floor. > My point is that prices will rise and find their time dependent values, in a way that will diminish the purchasing power of those you'd be attempting to help. It's true to the extent that the long term effect of a fixed UBI will be less than you would expect based on prices at the time adopted and the inflation that net beneficiaries would experience without the UBI. This is mitigated if the UBI formula tends to grow in nominal terms (e.g., because it's tied to a revenue source which grows with the economy, or indexed to inflation) and, in any case, it requires unlikely assumptions about elasticity to have it not be a real net benefit to the nominal net beneficiaries.
- ianai 9y agoEcon 101 should not use milk as a case study.
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago"Just enough to survive" gets purchased anyways - there wouldn't be a huge increase in demand for corn, cotton, and flour.
- djrogers 9y ago> The basics are largely standardized items. Do you think that if everyone in that story got a $2k BI check that the huts they live in would continue to rent for $300? Doubtful - very doubtful.
- hpcjoe 9y agoExactly. Rent seeking behavior, to extract more from tenants would be expected. This would spread. Causing other prices to rise.
- ianai 9y agoThere’s not going to be that much UBI to extract. Plus the assured UBI would empower people to move away from excise rent seekers.
- notyourday 9y agoUBI is going to go in the order of priority for: * roof over ones' head, no matter how shitty * food, no matter how shitty * minimum utilities * booze, drugs * other the first 3 would capture everything just as they do now.
- hpcjoe 9y agoI am going to assume I am more cynical than you on this. Rent seeking behavior is usually aimed hardest at those least likely to protest, or without resources to protest. Someone can rent seek another if the other person has no other effective choices, regardless of UBI or not. That is, UBI in isolation will likely fail. UBI is likely, at best, a bandaid, and should not be isolated. Should be part of a broader scope of programs that help people jumpstart a move, training, etc. That said, I do think we need it[1]. But it should be combined with other programs that help people (not redistributive programs per se, but things that help people do the things that they can't do or even consider doing now). [1] I think we need it, as disruption will continue across industries, geos, and will impact people in very negative ways. So we need a way for them to help themselves while they consider options. If this means helping them get mobile and settled at a new location, help finding a job, and training, that could be tremendous if linked with UBI.