3 ms·
Conventional weapons cannot destroy every population center in a large country in 30 minutes. You're right that WWII conventional bombing campaigns visited tot
by mikeash 9y ago
Conventional weapons cannot destroy every population center in a large country in 30 minutes.
You're right that WWII conventional bombing campaigns visited total destruction on cities to an extent that sometimes rivaled or surpassed what happened in Hiroshima or Nagasaki. But there are two key differences.
One is that those campaigns required hundreds of bombers and a near total effort from the Allied air forces to destroy one city. With nuclear weapons, that turns into hundreds of cities destroyed at once.
The other is that nuclear weapons have become much smaller and much more powerful. A conventional bombing raid could match the devastation of Hiroshima or Nagasaki, but could never come close to the devastation something like a W88 would cause to a major city. The bombs used on Japan barely fit in the largest bomber of the era, but a modern bomb can fit a dozen on a single missile.
A single Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine carries nearly 200 bombs. It could create an order of magnitude more destruction than all bombing raids of WWII combined (including the nuclear ones) less than an hour after being given the order. The US Navy operates 14 of them, and that's just one weapons system operated by one country.
Conventional weapons cannot do the things nuclear weapons do, not even close.
- pizzetta 9y agoAlso, Conventional weapons take great effort. One guy in N Korea with a nuclear weapon at his disposal vs Cuba and no nuclear weapon and we can see how difficult it is to imagine Cuba posing a real destabilizing threat vs N Korea. W/o nuclear weapons, N Korea, in order to invade S Korea and overwhelm it would need millions of troops clothed and fed for months, logistical support, etc. A couple of bombs and the same is achieved without spending billions a month in maintaining troop and armaments levels.