3 ms·
There are two inherent problems with SSNs: 1) No check digits--every number is valid. Adding a couple of extra digits would help tremendously 2) No ability t
by bsder 9y ago
There are two inherent problems with SSNs:
1) No check digits--every number is valid. Adding a couple of extra digits would help tremendously
2) No ability to retire/change the number--this is the big one. Once the criminals get your SSN--game over. You can't change it and shut the old one down. If you simply changed this, a lot of the issues with SSNs would go away.
Then there are the usage issues:
SSNs have two tasks which need to be separated:
1) Identification for "blocking" or "association" tasks. SSNs are fine for identity on a blocking task--ie. trying to shut something down, taxation identification, etc.
2) Identification for "allowing" tasks. SSNs are BAD for allowing tasks--new credit card, new bank account, etc. These kinds of tasks should always require SSN plus something else. This is where the primary failure modes are.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> No ability to retire/change the number You can change your SSN in certain situations [1]. [1] https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3789/can-i-change-my-social-security-number https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3789/can...
- bsder 9y agoIn reality, it rarely happens. The government makes the process so onerous that you have to be suffering horribly before they will even deign to think about it.
- siberianbear 9y agoWell, even that has its problems. Consider the case of Rachel Yould [1], who obtained a second SSN with her married name claiming abuse and stalking from her father. She was convicted of falsely using the second SSN and name as an originator and cosigner for hundreds of thousands of dollars in student loans in both her married and maiden names under false pretenses. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/10/04/the-scholar-jeffrey-toobin https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/10/04/the-scholar-je...
- throwawayjava 9y agoThat's a rather special case; the nature of the HALE program means that you can't allow someone to ask "do SSNs X and Y belong to the same natural person?". Whereas such a question would be entirely reasonable for the SS issuing authority to answer under more normal circumstances. (as for whether this case was actually a case of fraud, well, "the heart of Yould’s defense was that she thought she was allowed, under the hale program, to use the new Social Security number to apply for the loans above the lifetime cap and to use one name as a co-signer for loans to the other" pretty much sums it up for me... who would think that?!)
- ComputerGuru 9y agoCheck digits are not an isssue because it’s too easy to gain access to real numbers in the first place. We don’t have a problem with people providing technically invalid (I.e. never issued) social security numbers, only reusing ones that aren’t theirs.