3 ms·
It's only hard because PHBs (and Vice reporters, apparently) are willfully ignorant of public key cryptography.
by lisper 9y ago
It's only hard because PHBs (and Vice reporters, apparently) are willfully ignorant of public key cryptography.
- sohkamyung 9y agoIf you are referring to this article, do note that it wasn't written by a Vice reporter.
- lisper 9y agoHeh, good point. That makes it even more baffling. A CS professor should know better.
- rev_null 9y agoThe author acknowledged the existence of cryptographic solutions, but points out that what they lack is the ability to be memorized.
- lisper 9y agoAnything that can be memorized can be trivially compromised. There's nothing special about an SSN in this regard. It's the protocol that's broken. To prove you know the secret you have to reveal the secret. PKE is the only solution to this problem that works remotely.
- noncoml 9y agoI have two 2 questions when it comes to the usage of public key cryptography: 1. Who will be the CA and RA? 2. How do you prove your identity to RA?
- lisper 9y agoThe institutions that want to verify your identity should be their own CAs. If I were implementing a replacement for SSNs, I'd send out certs rendered as QR codes by physical mail. That's not perfect, but it's at least as secure as the current practice of sending out UIDs by physical mail. At least the is the possibility of getting the key safely inside a secure device and destroying the original. With the current protocol, in which the only way to prove you know a secret is to reveal the secret, it's completely hopeless.
- noncoml 9y agoI am not a PKI expert, so I may be missing something, but isn’t this chicken and egg problem? For someone to issue you a certificate, you have to prove your identity to them. How would you do that?