6 ms·
Replacing Social Security Numbers Is Harder Than You Think
- matheweis 9y ago> The problem underlying identity theft is not the existence of social security numbers, but rather, how little authentication is done for a person requesting credit. > Why don't they do [stronger authentication] for credit card requests? At a guess, it's because these stronger schemes are too inconvenient, and will drive away consumers who are trying to apply for credit. > If that guess is correct, it suggests that the real solution is regulatory: make credit providers liable for the full damages, including ongoing inconvenience, suffered by victims of identity theft. SSNs are not the problem; authentication commensurate with the risk to all parties, including especially individuals, is. Doesn't sound that hard to me...
- QAPereo 9y agoThis is Vice, everything is hard for them. Hey cover interesting stories with glorious incompetence, the Dunning-Kruger daily...
- sohkamyung 9y agoCurious, but did you see who was the author of the piece?
- chopin 9y agoOne could argue that neither the reputation of Vice nor the reputation of the author has anything to do with the quality of the article. You're both appealing to authority (or non-authority for the GP).
- sohkamyung 9y agoTrue. But the author's reputation in the security area makes me more inclined to listen to what he has to say. An article with the same title, but written by, say, a marketing specialist would probably get a more sceptical reading.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoIt's worth nothing that Appeal to Authority is a logical fallacy only when the authority is not an authority on the facts relevant to the argument. Deferring to a subject matter expert is logical.
- QAPereo 9y agoThere’s something to be said, especially when this site is so full of subject matter experts (although I am not one), for the notion that a discussion of somebody’s authority without including a discussion of the subject at hand is by definition, an appeal.
- QAPereo 9y agoI did, but I also saw this: They could also do things like send paper mail to the last long-term address, to confirm it. Why don't they do that for credit card requests? At a guess, it's because these stronger schemes are too inconvenient, and will drive away consumers who are trying to apply for credit. If that guess is correct, it suggests that the real solution is regulatory: make credit providers liable for the full damages, including ongoing inconvenience, suffered by victims of identity theft. SSNs are not the problem; authentication commensurate with the risk to all parties, including especially individuals, is. That’s a loooooot of guesses for my taste.
- matheweis 9y agoI want to clarify that it doesn’t sound like a hard technical problem. Bending the will of our politicians is much harder than it should be, unless you have a lot of money.
- rokhayakebe 9y agoWhat kind of money are we talking?
- colejohnson66 9y agoAccording to OpenSecrets[0] (MPAA PAC), it’s $100k - $200k, or about $1k - $5k per politician. That’s actually a lot less than I expected [0]: https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00139519 https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00139519
- keithb- 9y agoThis latest article about Detroit developers seems to support that [0]. A meager $300K dished out to politicians opened up the possibility of $700M-$1B plus the developers of these buildings can collect income tax from businesses and folks who occupy them for the next 20 years. What's the now?! [0] https://www.metrotimes.com/detroit/how-dan-gilbert-just-scored-up-to-1-billion-in-taxpayer-money-and-few-noticed/Content?oid=5981552 https://www.metrotimes.com/detroit/how-dan-gilbert-just-scor...
- throwawayjava 9y agoIt's a bit more subtle than that, in the same way that the cost of an ad is larger than the cost to place that ad somewhere. But on steroids. If you just show up and dump $300k on some politicians laps, the effect isn't likely to be particularly overwhelming. You need to cultivate relationships, wait for a good moment (when the money is disproportionately valuable to said politician), at least sell the perception that you're able and willing to dish up more in the future, etc. So the actual cost is a lot higher than the amount the politician actually receives.
- peteretep 9y agoSomebody should warn all the countries that don't have them or an equivalent
- lisper 9y agoIt's only hard because PHBs (and Vice reporters, apparently) are willfully ignorant of public key cryptography.
- sohkamyung 9y agoIf you are referring to this article, do note that it wasn't written by a Vice reporter.
- lisper 9y agoHeh, good point. That makes it even more baffling. A CS professor should know better.
- rev_null 9y agoThe author acknowledged the existence of cryptographic solutions, but points out that what they lack is the ability to be memorized.
- lisper 9y agoAnything that can be memorized can be trivially compromised. There's nothing special about an SSN in this regard. It's the protocol that's broken. To prove you know the secret you have to reveal the secret. PKE is the only solution to this problem that works remotely.
- noncoml 9y agoI have two 2 questions when it comes to the usage of public key cryptography: 1. Who will be the CA and RA? 2. How do you prove your identity to RA?
- lisper 9y agoThe institutions that want to verify your identity should be their own CAs. If I were implementing a replacement for SSNs, I'd send out certs rendered as QR codes by physical mail. That's not perfect, but it's at least as secure as the current practice of sending out UIDs by physical mail. At least the is the possibility of getting the key safely inside a secure device and destroying the original. With the current protocol, in which the only way to prove you know a secret is to reveal the secret, it's completely hopeless.
- makecheck 9y agoTen years ago, maybe. Today though, most people have devices that are both portable and computationally powerful. This has the potential to finally make secure keys that are actually convenient to use.
- noncoml 9y agoHow do you authenticate yourself when you need to rekey the app?
- kwhitefoot 9y agoThe equivalent of a social security number is used here in Norway (fødselsnummer) as my ID for all sorts of things. I use it when I log in to my bank, when I apply for a loan or credit card, when log in to the state run tax web site, when I apply for my pension, if I am admitted to hospital I will have a bracelet with my full name,and this number both as plain text and as a bar code. It's hardly a secret yet identity theft is not a major problem here.
- Sami_Lehtinen 9y agoExactly same situation in Finland. Yet in Finland there has been discussion about replacing it. But the current system isn't perfect. Address space is limited, as well as the current system indicates your gender, which gender neutral people don't like too much. In Finland we do have check code. Valid check byte is '0123456789ABCDEFHJKLMNPRSTUVWXY'. Format is DDMMYY then separator (if CC==19 then - elif + CC==20 then +)NNNC where NNN is sequence number and C is check byte. NNN contains also sex in format of parity, and even sequence numbers are used for females. -> Creates a limit of 500 identities / day / sex. Full example: 0123456-7890
- Sami_Lehtinen 9y agoAs stated, this can be a problem at times: "The couple said that the Finnish health care professionals have had no problem with them except that the administrative systems do not recognise a situation where a pregnant person has the male social security number."
- kristofferR 9y agoIt is used as the "username" for all those things, not as the "password". That's the major difference. To login to secure services like all government services, our banks, our digital post box etc we mostly use BankID. With BankID you enter your SSN, your personal password and a code from your 2FA key fob/phone app. https://www.bankid.no/en/ https://www.bankid.no/en/
- JSONwebtoken 9y ago
- bsder 9y agoThere are two inherent problems with SSNs: 1) No check digits--every number is valid. Adding a couple of extra digits would help tremendously 2) No ability to retire/change the number--this is the big one. Once the criminals get your SSN--game over. You can't change it and shut the old one down. If you simply changed this, a lot of the issues with SSNs would go away. Then there are the usage issues: SSNs have two tasks which need to be separated: 1) Identification for "blocking" or "association" tasks. SSNs are fine for identity on a blocking task--ie. trying to shut something down, taxation identification, etc. 2) Identification for "allowing" tasks. SSNs are BAD for allowing tasks--new credit card, new bank account, etc. These kinds of tasks should always require SSN plus something else. This is where the primary failure modes are.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> No ability to retire/change the number You can change your SSN in certain situations [1]. [1] https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3789/can-i-change-my-social-security-number https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3789/can...
- bsder 9y agoIn reality, it rarely happens. The government makes the process so onerous that you have to be suffering horribly before they will even deign to think about it.
- siberianbear 9y agoWell, even that has its problems. Consider the case of Rachel Yould [1], who obtained a second SSN with her married name claiming abuse and stalking from her father. She was convicted of falsely using the second SSN and name as an originator and cosigner for hundreds of thousands of dollars in student loans in both her married and maiden names under false pretenses. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/10/04/the-scholar-jeffrey-toobin https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/10/04/the-scholar-je...
- throwawayjava 9y ago
- njarboe 9y agoBanks and other issuers of credit just need to have high penalties for libeling people when then give false information to credit bureaus. $5,000 for a wrongly reported debt might make the banks more cautious about libeling people when fraudsters steal money from them by impersonating someone else.
- KekDemaga 9y agoIf I was a bank opposed to this plan here is how I would kill it. I'd say (well, I'd pay people with bullhorns and signs to say) the new requirements for 'wrongly reported debt' require banks to have greater ID requirements, greater ID requirements have been linked to less minority representation thus that plan is a racist plot. It would be dead in the water before you could draft the bill.
- jaclaz 9y agoMore examples of other countries (and their solutions, not particulrly hard) in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15210634 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15210634 The "secrecy" of the SSN is seemingly an US only problem, that all the rest of the word has already solved, one way or the other, so, no it it is not "harder than you think", it is "not hard at all" ...
- aneutron 9y agoI wonder if public-key crypto enabled ID-cards for example would be a good idea to solve this problem.
- gruez 9y agoSo... national ids? Not a politically popular option.
- nkristoffersen 9y agoAren’t we treating SSN cards like national IDs already? What make national ids not popular politically?
- revmoo 9y agoMail Yubikeys to citizens, let them auth into identity.gov and generate one-time use transaction codes. Done.
- DennisP 9y agoIt'd be really hard to change SSNs as database keys. But we could stop using knowledge of SSNs as authorization. Make a public database, put all the SSNs on it, and associate each with a public key.
- giberson 9y agoSeems to me like SSN is missing an open free (as in paid for by taxes) 2FA service. When I obtain a drivers license or passport (or some other process to confirm my identity at a government facility) that I should be able specify my 2FA medium (email address or phone number [text or call]). Any organization that wants to prevent identity theft should be able to do a 2FA challenge. As an individual I would receive a phone call or text or email "Acme Co. is processing a request to open up a new line of credit under your SSN. Did you initiate this action?" There should then be regulatory requirements on banks, insurance, etc that require 2FA confirmations before associating an SSN to your account.