5 ms·
[warning. rant head] This has to be the most mind-numbingly stupid thing I have seen the government do in the last couple of decades -- and that includes bad w
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
[warning. rant head]
This has to be the most mind-numbingly stupid thing I have seen the government do in the last couple of decades -- and that includes bad wars, if that's your thing.
Why can it be so bad? Because it screws with every single economic entity in the nation, in a way that pervasive, subtle, and micro-managing.
If you want to know where "1984" is, with Big Brother watching all of your moves, it's not bullshit programs like TIA. It's making you rat out the guy who is on disability but mows lawns on the side, or the guy who paints houses at nights without reporting the income so he can send his kid to school. Or the mom that babysits kids so that she can stay home.
Yes. These people are law-breakers. In a web of such complexity that 80% of IRS's own employees can't answer sample tax questions, we are all law-breakers. But this takes tax collection to a new low -- now I am going to be responsible for "double-checking" on my neighbor who sold me those used lawn mowers last year. I need to do my part to make sure he's reporting everything.
It is so outrageously stupid and infuriating that I still can't believe it is true. I'm beside myself. So if I eat at Burger King during the week when I travel, about the 120th time I buy a burger, I need to chalk them up for a 1099.
It's the worst thing for small businesses and the underground economy that I've ever heard of the government doing. It just can't be true.
</rant>
ADD: And don't get me started with some bullshit about how the agency hasn't decided yet how to enforce it. This is like saying the Congress voted to install cameras in everybody's homes, but that might not be so bad because the administrative work hasn't been done to decide who exactly gets a camera and when. As if this somehow mitigates things.
Also, for all of you folks down-voting me. Tell me I am wrong. I'm not a tax professional and I don't read the political spin sites. The only reason I've commented now is that this is the 3rd or 4th time I've seen this posted on HN. So please. I would love to be wrong about this.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 16y agoMan, talk about hyperbole. This is probably a terrible idea economically, but it's hardly a Nineteen Eighty-Four scenario. It's not becoming illegal to say "the IRS sucks", the IRS will not have cameras in your house looking for the slightest sign of dissent, and it'll actually be nearly impossible to get imprisoned for anything at all (tax penalties are generally merely more taxes, unless you deliberately lie). Also, you, as an individual, won't have to send 1099s to anyone, whether your baby-sitter or lawn-mower or Office Depot. Only businesses will, though this does include small businessmen and sole proprietorships (the way to distinguish a sole proprietor from "just a person" is by whether you're deducting those expenses as business expenses on a Schedule C or not).
- sprout 16y agoIt kind of reminds me of Schneier's explanation of cyberwarfare as if an enemy army invaded and all got in line at the BMV. Except in this case it's a horrible tyrranical oligarchy that instead of making your life hell gives you a few extra forms to fill out every week.
- swolchok 16y agoIf you're trying to Google the referenced explanation, he said "DMV", and it's here: http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/07/the_threat_of_c.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/07/the_threat_of_...
- madair 16y agoWhen everyone is a lawbreaker enforcement becomes selective, you could say arbitrary.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoAnd the enforcer gets to decide who is allowed to live normally and who isn't. And that, IMO, is the scariest part of the whole thing. Don't piss off the DA or the police.
- Confusion 16y agoThis is a 1984 scenario, because virtually everyone becomes a criminal, as everyone will fail to fill out all the proper 1099's. Consequently, at any time you do something the government doesn't like, they can come and get you for those incorrectly or unfiled 1099's. (Reiterating what madair already replied to sprout, but I felt his point was not as clear as it could be)
- _delirium 16y agoThat would require that "virtually everyone" is a business, which is not the case. Somewhere less than 5% of the U.S. population run businesses. Again, contrary to the misinformation rampant in this discussion, individual expenditures that are not business expenses won't require 1099s. (Did anyone even read the linked article?) Even if that were not the case, it would hardly be a 1984 scenario, especially given that there are no criminal penalties for failing to file the 1099s. That's pretty absurdly embarrassing hyperbole that makes you sound like you came from DailyKos or something. The war on drugs is more of a 1984 scenario than requiring 1099s is, especially since it comes with widespread criminal penalties.
- ubernostrum 16y ago[warning: common sense ahead] Seriously. Chill out. The thing hasn't even been finalized yet, and there'll be public comment periods and reviews and all sorts of other stuff providing people an opportunity to go froth at the mouth about how this will be the end of the world or whatever. In the meantime: take a deep breath. Relax. Read and learn. Get as much information as you can instead of going off half-cocked. And actually think through the things you'd like to say, because hyperbolic rants don't do anyone a damn bit of good.
- Retric 16y agoIt's my understanding there is a specific exemption to any purchases made with a Credit Card. So now it's non CC company to company transactions > 600$/year which is a far smaller pool. The absolute worst possible case is total revenue / 600$ but the reality is most companies have a fairly small number of suppliers. So something like Ln (revenue / 1000) for the average small business.
- terrellm 16y agoThat's my understanding as explained by my CPA a few minutes ago.
- oconnore 16y agoEffectively banning cash/check/MO/wire transactions doesn't make this any better. This needs to go away.
- mcantelon 16y agoThis will likely boost the prepaid anonymous credit card business (for those who don't like the government being able to track how they spend their own money).
- DLWormwood 16y ago> prepaid anonymous credit card business Haven’t these been targeted by government regulation in the last couple years? I remember reading about police agencies wanting these banned (along with pre-paid cellphones) for enabling the drug trade.
- gills 16y agoDon't worry, it's just a setup to make VAT look good by comparison.
- yters 16y agoIncidentally, free-enterprise as you describe it is essential for freedom of speech. If everyone's income becomes incumbent on the government, then they don't want to say anything to piss off said government.