4 ms·
When the story about the Bodega startup[0] came out, it occurred to me that what they were trying to do was essentially what Japan is already doing with vending
by krapp 9y ago
When the story about the Bodega startup[0] came out, it occurred to me that what they were trying to do was essentially what Japan is already doing with vending machines - automate retail at scale. Unfortunately, Bodega tried to undermine, transform and rebrand the local culture in a way that many found offensive, but that aside, I wonder what particular cultural elements make vending machines seem so successful in Japan, but not as much in the US?
Maybe Amazon could bring back Automats[1]?
[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15291795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15291795
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automat
- davidw 9y ago> particular cultural elements make vending machines seem so successful in Japan Not being vandalized is mentioned in the article. People in Italy were always kind of surprised to hear about US newspaper machines - the ones where you put in some coins - and you can take out as many newspapers as you want, essentially. They'd joke that people would regularly take them all in Italy, and in Naples they'd probably just haul off the whole machine, change, newspapers and all.
- krapp 9y ago>People in Italy were always kind of surprised to hear about US newspaper machines - the ones where you put in some coins - and you can take out as many newspapers as you want, essentially Honestly, I have no idea why those things even exist or how they make anyone money. It's baffling.
- davidw 9y agoI guess people are honest enough that they buy the newspapers. Compare and contrast: in Italy, until recently, you could only buy newspapers from newsstands, who had some kind of monopoly on their sales. You couldn't get them from a grocery store, and certainly not from a vending machine.
- jefurii 9y agoNope, different. Many of those pictures have vending machines sitting outside neighborhood mom-and-pop stores. From my experience living in Japan, those machines are most likely owned/leased by the owner of the store, who stocks them and collects the profits. They function as a labor-saving device for high-trafficked items and a way to sell during off-hours. My understanding of Bodega is that they want to replace the mom-and-pop store with a centralized vertically-integrated company (theirs).
- prawn 9y ago"They function as a labor-saving device for high-trafficked items and a way to sell during off-hours." Seemed to be Bodega's plan also. If they want to go after a particular market, so be it. I'd rather it be a new business than a venture by a corporate giant. That opportunity has been available to every mom-and-pop store too, right? Even if it was just one vending machine in one nearby apartment building? I can appreciate the romance of corner stores, but if they're not innovating or marketing, they risk losing out to others who are.
- Animats 9y agoBodega isn't innovating much. There are several other systems where you access a big refrigerator using an app and get food.
- prawn 9y agoIf they're not innovating or offering something of value, they'll fail. I think avoiding products that spoil is easy but smart. Saves somewhat on transport constantly replenishing the cabinet, refrigeration, etc. Focusing your product catalogue is innovation to some extent.
- mc32 9y agoI don't get the bodega hooplah. Every startup is taking away some way of making a living of someone else. It's like saying pizza hut coopted Italian pizza joints and drove Italian pizza makers out of biz. Sure, it did, but aside from the fact jobs were lateralized, what's the big deal about transforming the biz? Same with Uber et all.
- cwkoss 9y agoIt's because New Yorkers have a romanticized ideal of bodegas.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThe main big deal is that it managed to lower the price of those products. The TL;DR effect of that is that it removed people from the middle class and drove most of the jobs to the lower class (e.g. pizza delivery, production line pizza making), and a few to the upper class (a handful of companies owning the pizza market, instead of dozens if not hundreds of local pizza restaurants). Same with Uber, it drives the price down and turns taxis into a fairly exclusive and respectable job (I'm mostly thinking about the London Black Cabs or the fancy Mercedes taxis I see here in NL) to a race to the bottom. The same happened to the postal service, turning it from a respectable middle class uniformed government or semi-governmental job to something stay-at-home moms do part-time. Mind you, the market changed and snail mail is nowhere near what it used to be. The markets for pizza and taxis haven't changed that much in comparison though.
- protomyth 9y agoIn the US, RedBox (well, CoinStar in general) seems to have figured out the right formula for successful vending machines.
- spookthesunset 9y ago> I wonder what particular cultural elements make vending machines seem so successful in Japan, but not as much in the US Mostly a lack of, for a better term, conformity. There is very little crime in Japan and people trust each other way more. In the US, those vending machines would get vandalized and probably stripped of their metal in under a week. Even if there was a market demand for them, the cost to service those machines would be astronomical.
- mirimir 9y agoThat's why there are upholstered seats in Japanese subways, but typically not in US subways.