3 ms·
An interesting argument, but the lookup table argument falls flat. The number of inputs is pretty much infinite, not finite like he says. I emailed him this,
by ars 16y ago
An interesting argument, but the lookup table argument falls flat.
The number of inputs is pretty much infinite, not finite like he says.
I emailed him this, I'll post here if he replies:
I think you are incorrect about the lookup table. Just
walking around a city will provide more input permutations
than any lookup table could possibly encode.
You assumed that responses are always deterministic, but
actually peoples behavior is influenced by what they have
seen recently. Or even what they have been asked recently!
Every lookup table will also have to include the result
of choosing any question from the lookup table - and in
what order.
The possible number of orderings of that grows far faster
than any finite lookup table could encode, because simply
asking a question in the lookup table changes the answer
to all further questions.
- ihodes 16y agoNot at all! When walking around a city, our brains filter out less relevant input, stopping it from entering our own massive lookup table with heuristics. For example; I hear a gunshot and see a flower. I'm not going to notice the flower. I only consider the gunshot and begin to process that information, deciding the give precedence to figuring out an escape route over botanical pondering.
- ars 16y agoActually advertising science has definitively proven that that is not true. Watch "Mind Control Marketing" by Derren Brown for proof.
- hugh3 16y agoAdvertising science has proven that you notice flowers when you hear gunshots? What sort of crazy experiments have they been doing, and what does it have to do with advertising? And why have I never heard the term "advertising science" until just now?
- wlievens 16y agoThe link is dead obvious: subliminal messaging. Not in a tinfoil-hat-CIA way, but in a product placement kind of way. It's dead obvious that that's very valuable (in a $ sense) science!
- AndrewDucker 16y agoI think you're confusing "finite" and "small enough that I can imagine something that size". A billion operations per billionth of a second for a billion years is still finite, it's just big.
- ars 16y agoI am not confusing them. My argument is that each time you add a question to the table, you need to encode an answer that depends on all the other questions asked. Meaning the number of answers is exponential (actually factorial) to the number of questions in it. Such a table is essentially infinite. i.e. if you have 10 questions you have 3 million possible answers. But with a million questions you have 8 x 10^5565708 answers. I hope you realize how big this number is.
- almost 16y agoThe difference between infinite and "essentially infinite" is that one is infinite and one finite. That is a large number, but it's not infinitely large.
- ars 16y agoYou are speaking about math, I am speaking about complexity theory.
- jerf 16y agoThe number of states the observable universe can have is quite possibly "finite" given some reasonable assumptions about QM and either a temporal end-point (big rip, crunch) or a spatial one ("after 50 billion light years I can no longer observe anything of interest"). With those assumptions, there's a finite limit on the space-time extent you can be observing, and within that volume a finite number of permutations of waves, even if we discard the need for them to have a plausible history just to bump the count up. As large as that number may be, following up on a discussion from yesterday, I would bet BB(10) is quite a bit larger. (Failing that BB(20) certainly is, because I suspect the TM to directly simulate the situation I just named could fit within 20 states. Mere permutation isn't actually that Turing-complex.) The human lookup table is a much smaller finite subset of that, for any definition of human you could name. Enormous, but also "enormously" smaller than the other things I've described.