5 ms·
FBI Hunt for 2 Missing Pigs Reveals Federal Cover-Up of Barbaric Factory Farms
- Overtonwindow 9y agoFor reference you might consider watching the excellent documentaries "Our Daily Bread," and "Food, inc"
- partycoder 9y ago"Our daily bread" is particularly interesting. They try to show an unbiased perspective, by no adding a narrator, or music. Just showing the process step by step. The scene with the chicken vacuum in the warehouse explains what "cage free" chicken really means. I think it's rather misleading...
- cup 9y agoI think its hard to morally justify consuming animal products in this day and age, under a capitalist system where animal welfare is not recognised. For people that want to eat or use animal products you should consider hunting for your own food, rearing your own chickens or just cutting back. The ecological problems and the blatant disregard for animals rights are too much and a top down approach doesn't seem possible considering the power these big agricorps have. It's time for individuals to make the conscious decision to opt out.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThe moral pitch for abstinence from meat in general, or meat one hasn’t killed themselves, is one of the most unsuccessful animal rights campaigns in history. People like meat. Those same people are moving into cities. The population is not going to hunt. Moral arguments are fun to make, but without a plan they’re just bloviation. Pushing people to prioritise humane legislation, advocating a switch from intelligent animals and related methods, while less emotionally satisfying, are altogether more effective.
- thwraway29 9y agoThere are many coherent, good arguments against animal product consumption which have nothing to do with morality. Environmental cost of production and subsequent effect on health are two popular arguments for abandoning animal foods. There are also the poor workers in slaughterhouses and surrounding communities to be concerned about, e.g.: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/20/north-carolina-hog-industry-pig-farms https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/20/north-caroli...
- edejong 9y agoYet here in the Netherlands I see many coworkers and friends moving partly or totally away from meat due to moral concerns. Others choose to pay higher prices for livestock raised in better conditions.
- distances 9y agoSame in Finland. Lots of people who have no intention of going full vegetarian have nonetheless added meat-free dishes and locally, ethically produced meat for their diets.
- white-flame 9y agoAnother problem with such moral pitches is that at no place can a clear line be drawn between life that is okay to simply raise & kill for feed, and life that isn't. There's all sorts of attempts to morally distinguish between eating furry animals that have big glassy eyes and birth cute little babies, and other less anthropomorphically-empathetic animals such as birds, fish, or insects. That certainly may be a preference, but it's not a scrutable predicate with any shared sense of objectivity. Any time someone draws any specific moral line based on life or intelligence, everybody else raises an eyebrow about the legitimacy of that line. Even taking it all the way down, plants have communities, negotiate resource exchange, have fear & pain responses, and are basically just as alive as anything else. They just eat differently and move slower. And yet we eat their live young (care for some sprouts in your salad?)
- 9y ago
- ogre_magi 9y agoI have no trouble morally justifying it.
- naasking 9y agoWell, maybe no trouble justifying it, but I'd hazard it's likely not a morally sound argument.
- kiba 9y agoI don't morally justify it, no matter how barbaric it is. For me, meat just taste too good.
- thwraway29 9y agoThat's not a justification, though, as there is a victim involved. Also, it is not the meat that tastes good, but rather cooking with plant-based seasonings, spices and additions which make a decaying carcass actually palatable. Given that it's possible to emulate the same nutritional profiles and even taste of meat with entirely non-animal derived ingredients, the choice here is pretty clear.
- tdb7893 9y agoI love hot dogs, tacos, and pepperoni pizza too much to be vegetarian but what I did was just cut down my meat intake. I eat meat for no more than 3 meals a week
- megous 9y agoAnimals certainly don't care about your inner mental processes. They can only experience consequences of your actions. So your first sentence seems quite meaningless.
- zzalpha 9y agoTBH, I'm not sure what you're trying to say, here. The parent's statement was simple: they don't care about the "barbarism" of eating meat. I think it's taken as a given that they therefore don't much care about what animals experience as the consequence of their actions. So I'm not sure how your comment is relevant or what you meant to achieve by making it. Could you clarify?
- megous 9y agoI didn't understand the point of the first part of the comment: > I don't morally justify it, no matter how barbaric it is. It wouldn't matter either way even if he tried to morally justify it. Like with people eating foie gras. They justify it by saying that it's their right to eat what they want. Meanwhile poor geese can't care less, doesn't have any concept of morality, just suffers either way, because the result is the same. People just like eating their ill livers. And it doesn't matter if they justify it or not.
- oh_sigh 9y agoOpting out simply isn't good enough, because you may just end up translating animal suffering into human suffering if you just eat vegetarian products without knowing how it is sourced. What is more moral, eating a steak from a cow that was killed for its meat by decently paid, respected workers - or - eating a chocolate bar made with palm oil whose products were farmed using slave and child labor?
- distances 9y agoThis is not a logical line of thought. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Not_as_bad_as https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Not_as_bad_as
- oh_sigh 9y agoThat is not at all what my line of thought was. My point was that you can't just cut meat out of your diet and think that you are behaving more moral than before. If you increase, say, your chocolate, or palm oil, tea, etc consumption, then you may be increasing human suffering compared to when you were an omnivore.
- distances 9y agoI don't see this making any sense at all. Why would eating less meat result in more palm oil consumption? For me this sounds like a complete nonsense justification for not reducing the amount of meat in one's diet.
- squeaky-clean 9y agoBecause you still need some kind of food to replace that meat with? The point being that not all foods are ethically made. It's not as easy as meat == always the only immoral food choice and not-meat == always good. By reducing meat consumption, if you replace it with other non ethically sourced foods, are yo really helping? And if those new foods take advantage of human workers and slavery, is that better than an animal's suffering? They aren't saying "Well plants can also be bad, so just stick with meat." It's "if you switch blindly without any research, you may actually ending causing more suffering for people and animals in the world than if you had stuck with meat." Edit since I can't reply to posts below mine. It's not just about calories. I really think this sentence was overlooked from the parent post way up: "What is more moral, eating a steak from a cow that was killed for its meat by decently paid, respected workers - or - eating a chocolate bar made with palm oil whose products were farmed using slave and child labor?" Research conditions of cacao workers if you think this example is a joke or being made up.
- whipoodle 9y agoNobody wants to hear it. They just don't.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoActivists were filming, under cover, a farm being heinous to pigs, saw two piglets in a dire state, and absconded with them. The FBI got involved to get the pigs back. There’s a legitimate question around why public dollars are being spent on a relatively minor crime. But that legitimacy is lost by the article blowing a reasonable law enforcement response to a theft into a “cover up”. I have a pet theory to explain why animal rights organisations are so often ineffective. The organisations that effect change get fewer donations than those that piss people off. This, together with institutional prerogatives, results in the villification of reasonable le enforcement actions over trying to pass legislation.
- distances 9y agoIs such animal mistreatment in a farm not a crime in the states in question? I find it absurd and sad that the "crime" of documentation and rescue even enters the discussion, when the FBI resources should clearly be used to investigate the far, far greater misdeed taking place at the farm itself.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Is such animal mistreatment in a farm not a crime in the states in question? I don’t believe it is—the article specifically says it’s illegal elsewhere but not in America. In the states where it might be illegal, the laws in question were passed as a result of reasonable debates balancing the cost of food against the wellness of animals. All-or-nothing often yields the latter. > I find it absurd and sad that the "crime" of documentation and rescue While falsifying intent for purposes of undercover reporting is illegal in some states, stealing is illegal everywhere. If they had to act, they should have immediately given the piglets to the (a) farm’s management or (b) police. Worst case: immediately hire a lawyer upon return to the shelter. The methods they used were dumbly deployed.
- distances 9y ago> If they had to act, they should have immediately given the piglets to the (a) farm’s management or (b) police. You know very well yourself that this would not have been a good idea at all if their goal was to help the mistreated piglets and bring wider awareness for the farming practices.
- trhway 9y ago> The FBI agents ordered staff and volunteers to stay away from the animals and then approached the piglets. To obtain the DNA samples, the state veterinarians accompanying the FBI used a snare to pressurize the piglet’s snout, thus immobilizing her in pain and fear, and then cut off close to two inches of the piglet’s ear. >The piglet’s pain was so severe, and her screams so piercing, that the sanctuary’s staff members screamed and cried. Even the FBI agents were so sufficiently disturbed by the resulting trauma, that they directed the veterinarians not to subject the second piglet to the procedure. a blatant act of animal torture.
- mschuster91 9y ago> a blatant act of animal torture. If a German veterinarian would do this, he'd instantly lose his license, and the cops who "supervised" this would be under investigation for dereliction of duty. There is so much that has gone wrong in this case, on all levels from the cops over a judge who actually authorized the warrant to the "veterinarians".