3 ms·
100 operations is really small sample for something that happens once in a 100. If you have chance 1/100 of death then with sample 100 you have to have 0 or 1
by scotty79 16y ago
100 operations is really small sample for something that happens once in a 100.
If you have chance 1/100 of death then with sample 100 you have to have 0 or 1 deaths to fit in 60% but with sample 200 you can have 0,1,2,3 deaths to still fit.
It's just 60% is harsh limit for small samples. There should be some lower limit on sample size you have to gather for given probability before you start judging. Either that or threshold should depend on sample size and probability, but limiting sample size might be easier to understand for general public.
- dinedal 16y agoI wish that journalistic integrity extended into statistical analysis, and that the bar for understanding of basic statistics were raised so that someone with a high school degree would be as irked as you or I about poor excuses for analysis.
- goodside 16y agoWishing for normal people to understand statistics isn't reasonable. I'd also like a pony. But the first point is important: journalists shouldn't be allowed to publish statistical musings without some oversight from a statistician, which any reputable paper would have on staff anyway to avoid basic mistakes. Journalists would never be allowed to speculate as freely as this in deciding questions of climate science or molecular biology, but once it's a question of statistics everyone is instantly an expert.
- hugh3 16y agoPerhaps statistics, (of the relatively advanced variety rather than the mean-mode-median variety), should be inserted into every high school student's curriculum. It is, after all, far more important to the life of the average citizen than, say, trigonometry or calculus. And it ought to be easier to understand.
- vannevar 16y agoI think perhaps you're missing the point. Even if you run the number to 1000, or even 10,000, you're eventually going to get outliers. In the real world, precisely because most people have no understanding of statistics, significant public policy decisions with real impact on people's lives would be made on the basis of events that happened merely by chance. Cancer clusters for instance trigger all kinds of legal action and political grandstanding, yet such outliers are statistically inevitable.