37 ms·
From reading the article, I don't believe the statement "We’ll Have Evidence of Aliens–If They Exist–By 2035." An alien civilization broadcasting via radio at t
by gwbas1c 9y ago
From reading the article, I don't believe the statement "We’ll Have Evidence of Aliens–If They Exist–By 2035." An alien civilization broadcasting via radio at the same moment we're looking could be very unlikely.
[Edit] Who's to say that we're going to broadcast via radio for thousands or millions of years? What if, in 300 years, we discover a much better system? Then we can reasonably assume that a 400 year radio burst is the sign of a species developing intelligence. We can also reasonably assume that SETI chose a poor indicator in their search.
- imglorp 9y agoOr more reasonably, assuming only current physics and assuming they mostly stay in their system, they simply don't incur the inefficiency of broadcast radio any more. For example point-to-point using lasers is reasonable, and we'd never see it here unless we were the target.
- bluGill 9y agoRadio is likely to be useful for millions of years. Each form of communication has pros and cons. Radio has some advantages over the alternatives, and so we are likely to use it. How much we cannot know without first knowing what the alternative is though.
- planteen 9y agoThe alternative is optical which is superior to radio waves at planetary distances and further from the perspective of NASA. https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/heo/scan/engineering/technology/txt_opticalcomm_benefits.html https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/heo/scan/engineering/techn...
- bluGill 9y agoright, but we are trying to detect on planet communications, which we believe we can do. Once we determine that someone is out there we can ask if/how we can contact them.
- yodon 9y agoWhich is why they are also thinking about signals like neutrinos and gravity waves (which are much harder to produce but much better suited to interstellar distances). While it's never possible to say "everything has been discovered/invented" we know a great deal about the types of particles and waves that can exist at realistic energy levels for use in communication systems because those energy scales have been so well studied. The odds that there is "new physics" to be discovered at a scale that will supplant radio waves for broadcast communications on a terrestrial scale are pretty low.
- jerf 9y ago"neutrinos and gravity waves (which are much harder to produce but much better suited to interstellar distances)." No, they aren't. Both are freakishly difficult to detect, and we have no reason at this point to expect that to ever change. And gravity waves are actually terrible for interstellar distances because it is completely unclear how you would produce a source of gravity waves powerful enough to transmit across interstellar distances, and also transmit in a beam. If you can't transmit in a beam, you're stuck with very unfavorable dropoffs as distance increases. It is also unclear why, having built the utterly massive complexes for transmission or detection of gravity waves, or the massive complexes required for high-probability neutrino reception (transmission in their case is a bit simpler, though collimating the beam is rough) it would not simply be easier to use electromagnetic waves, which are by comparison so easy that if we had a receiver in another star system we could transmit to them today. Barring some major revelation in physics, aliens will use electromagnetic waves because everything else is literally (and I mean that in its original correct sense) dozens of orders of magnitude worse. Smart aliens do not demonstrate how much smarter they are than us by using engineering solutions dozens of orders magnitude inferior to what we could build today. However, as my previous text implies and as other commenters have already pointed out, the problem there is that efficiency is obtained at that scale with beams, not broad transmission. The galaxy could be hopping with point-to-point links and they would be much harder for us to notice. (They wouldn't be impossible, because there would be some scattering on the interstellar medium. But they'd be much more difficult than if we were directly the target.)
- 9y ago
- goatlover 9y agoBut if there are 10,000 to several million of them, then the odds of detecting a signal go up as we look at more stars. Of course if there's only a few, then we might not see any evidence for them. But 10,000 would probably be detectable at some point in our search.