3 ms·
> I'm on the hype train That’s the intellectual blind spot which is making this so hard to understand: you’re invested in the technology and want to see it suc
by acdha 9y ago
> I'm on the hype train
That’s the intellectual blind spot which is making this so hard to understand: you’re invested in the technology and want to see it succeed, which means you’re inclined to minimize every downside and boost every possible use without asking whether something is better in addition to being possible.
Being old enough to remember when the internet was starting to go mainstream, there were op-eds like that but they got plenty of pushback because there were so many new things which you could do on the internet which were either impossible, unaffordable, or too cumbersome before. Yes, a modem connection was too slow to play a movie but you could read newspapers around the world, send email to anyone and have it arrive in seconds, download software or photos instead of having to drive to the store, research and trade stocks, chat, etc. and there was a clear path for technological improvements making that experience better over time. The average person could easily see things they’d like to do and the costs were getting more approachable every year.
In contrast, we have a ton of blockchain hype without a single legal use which solves a problem normal people care about better than existing, well-tested technology. There’s a lot of “that’ll change once these fundamental design flaws are solved in a way we don’t yet know how to do” hype being peddled by people who stand to profit if everyone buys in but, as during the dotcom bubble, that should inspire more rather than less skepticism.
- notahacker 9y agoI think the key thing is that even without understanding the technology most consumers could see "before I couldn't get access to this information/correspondence/map/ticket/catalogue/advice/news/opinion/porn and now I can" as an obvious life enhancement in a way which having anonymous miners as counterparties rather than the company providing the service and their bank isn't (not even if expressed in terms of a 3% fee reduction). Whereas with blockchain it seems like it's often the evangelists not understanding the consumers: to use examples from the article, I really care that flight delay information is easily available which is why the internet was much better than call centres but I really don't care whether it uses a distributed database or not and wouldn't fly with anyone I worried wouldn't honour the terms of my ticket. I care that ridesharing services have good availability, routing and safety, I really don't want them to be transparent about my location and payments to any interested party. Now, there are many technologies which are very useful for certain use cases despite the consumer failing to grasp what's going on behind the scenes, from Java VMs to graph databases to torrents, but certain things tend to be true of them (i) they weren't as exciting opportunities as the internet even if billion dollar businesses were built on them (ii) the developers explaining why existing solutions were good enough if not more optimal in many respects were often right.
- acdha 9y agoExactly – during the 90s I heard from a ton of companies looking to get on the web. They needed help understanding the technology but in most cases there were clear benefits from making things easier to find, customize, etc. I’ve seen the same trend for blockchain evangelists to have gone deep into that technology but have only a cursory understanding of the businesses they’re trying to enter. A great example is the retail purchase model which always comes up in Bitcoin discussions, which ignores the fact that most people think credit cards are just fine and like things such as fraud protection more than the hypothetical chance of a fractional overhead reduction. There might be room there but it’s an uphill fight and the value is capped at the lowest Visa, et al. are willing to drop their merchant fees to. I think your comment about selling tech is also important because the model puts some unusual constraints on it: you can sell to developers by focusing on tech details but how many developers are paid to work on problems which require trustless distributed systems and low transaction volumes? Most big systems require the opposite.
- CryptoPunk 9y ago>>In contrast, we have a ton of blockchain hype without a single legal use which solves a problem normal people care about better than existing, well-tested technology. Maybe this is your blind spot? You assume it has to be legal to be useful. But in any case, there are legal use cases that work today: sending money with very little friction, including no need to provide a trusted third party or the payee your personally identifiable information. With Ethereum, we'll soon have social networks and markets that participants can trust will not have fees increased and terms changed once the platform has become dominant. So you can have monopolies without monopolists.
- acdha 9y ago> Maybe this is your blind spot? You assume it has to be legal to be useful. I'm looking at what it takes to go mainstream — if it's predominately used for illegal activity, that'll deter normal people and legitimate businesses from adopting it and increases the likelihood of government regulation. As a simple example, how many people would use a tumbler if that started being seen as probable cause for a money laundering investigation? > But in any case, there are legal use cases that work today: sending money with very little friction and with no need to provide a trusted third party or the payee your personally identifiable information. How many people care enough about removing the trusted third party that they will use this instead of Google Wallet, Square, Venmo, etc. (and, soon, Apple Pay)? Some people value that but it seems unlikely that it's enough to make up for the smaller network, processing delays, and exchange fees.
- CryptoPunk 9y ago>>As a simple example, how many people would use a tumbler if that started being seen as probable cause for a money laundering investigation? Filesharing is arguably in this category and maybe shows that it's possible that something not generally used for legal purposes and not in the mainstream can nonetheless become widely used. But yes there is certainly a risk. >Some people value that but it seems unlikely that it's enough to make up for the smaller network, processing delays, and exchange fees. Right now cryptocurrency is in its infancy, so it has a lot of drawbacks, but it has obvious advantages that anyone can see, like being able to send money from your computer, without first registering with Google Wallet, Square, Venmo, etc, to anyone, anywhere in the world who also has the software installed on an internet connected device. This is a fundamental innovation in money transfer. You're right that it may not be enough to overcome the advantages that large trusted third parties can bring to make it go mainstream, but the advantages it has are obvious enough that people can see it potentially doing so.