4 ms·
If you’re willing to give it the space needed I’d definitely recommend The Unconsoled[1]. It’s by quite a long way the best description of dream state that I’ve
by robin_reala 9y ago
If you’re willing to give it the space needed I’d definitely recommend The Unconsoled[1]. It’s by quite a long way the best description of dream state that I’ve ever read.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unconsoled https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unconsoled
- bbctol 9y agoYes! I might spend the rest of the day plugging The Unconsoled, which I think is one of those masterpieces that's doomed to forever be underrated because experiencing it is so unpleasant. It captures exactly what it feels like to have a long, stressful nightmare in a way that no other work of art has. Unfortunately, that means reading it feels exactly like having a long, stressful nightmare.
- retsibsi 9y agoI'm not trying to be a smartarse or anything, this is a genuine question: what makes a book like that valuable to you? If it's very unpleasant to read, and captures an experience you are already familiar with, why are you glad that you read it? It seems to me that the value of unpleasant art is usually that it teaches us something: perhaps it helps us to empathise with people we previously didn't understand, or gives us a new perspective on a topic we care about, or makes us care about a topic we had previously neglected, etc. But if The Unconsoled precisely captured a feeling you were already familiar with, all I can see it doing is giving you a sense of connection: ah, yes, someone else really does get what my nightmares are like; I'm not alone. Which is not worthless, but seems likely to be outweighed by the unpleasantness of the reading experience. Am I just wrong on that last point, or have I missed something else entirely?
- bbctol 9y agoI just... appreciate art, I guess? It's a beautiful book. The experience of reading it is unpleasant, but that's separate from aesthetic appreciation--I don't read books just to be taught lessons.
- archagon 9y agoIs it audiobook-able, or does he play with the structure of the text?
- robin_reala 9y agoIt suspect it would be OK, albeit confusing. On the other hand, it doesn’t exist on Audible so maybe not?
- archagon 9y agoGoogle tells me there's an audiobook version out there, probably. (Audiobooks seem to be the only way I can get myself to read these days!)
- twoodfin 9y agoGood question. On this recommendation, I immediately went to Audible, but they apparently don't have the '99 books-on-tape version. I can say that I've "read" more Ishiguro through audiobooks than paper, and that they've all been excellent. Rosalyn Landor's Never Let Me Go was particularly moving. The first-person perspective used by Ishiguro in several of his novels lends itself very well to the format. When We Were Orphans isn't typically considered one of his stronger works, but as a "told tale" I found it fascinating.
- tacomonstrous 9y agoAmong my all-time favorites, and my recommending it to my now wife played a small role in us getting together, so I'll always have a soft spot for it. Certainly the most intense literary experience I've had.