3 ms·
"within mathematics there are things that cannot be calculated algorithmically" What is missing is the proof of the opposite: that the human brain can calculat
by Tichy 16y ago
"within mathematics there are things that cannot be calculated algorithmically"
What is missing is the proof of the opposite: that the human brain can calculate those things. I don't think it can - mathematics is the tool we use to think about them, after all.
- snikolov 16y agoI think you're right. The brain is a very specialized computing machine, and it evolved for a specific purpose.* Evolution doesn't reward general computing capabilities. Hence, computers are vastly more general than brains. If something is, in principle, uncomputable, than there is no chance that a brain can compute it. *Sure, a networked system of neuron-like "units" might have general computing capabilities. It's as if you saw a fully functional modern computer for the first time, and it only gets fed arithmetic problems - the system itself is much more powerful and general than that, and you could hack around and make it do other things once you understand how it manages to do arithmetic. The brain is kind of like that too -- it gets fed stimuli and it has evolved to process those stimuli. Yet it might be that a computational system made of a network of neurons could be a lot more powerful and general than that in principle.
- kd0amg 16y agoWhat is missing is the proof of the opposite: that the human brain can calculate those things. Really, we have no proof either way. The ability to hand-trace computation makes the human Turing-complete. Whether the Turing machine is human-complete is an open question, and I expect it to remain so. Each side of the can think vs. can't think debate works under the assumption that Turing machines are or are not human-complete, and they mostly build their cases on that assumption while claiming the other side's is wrong (without fully proving or disproving either assumption).