4 ms·
I dont understand the word Forcing here. Norway had a choice to continue denying The one China policy. Putting pressure on Norway thru various means is not forc
by ekianjo 9y ago
I dont understand the word Forcing here. Norway had a choice to continue denying The one China policy. Putting pressure on Norway thru various means is not forcing. Forcing would be done via a military operation leaving little choice.
- provost 9y ago> Forcing would be done via a military operation leaving little choice. Blackmail, threats, deceit, etc are other ways to force. Not saying that occurred here, just that your definition has a narrow scope.
- ekianjo 9y agoId rather say you are narrowing the scope of free will. Succumbing to pressure is not the same as being forced.
- sgift 9y agoWhat a brilliant piece of newspeak. "You weren't forced to do what the mugger wanted. You just succumbed to their pressure."
- otp124 9y agoBeing forced IS succumbing to pressure
- rdlecler1 9y agoYou clearly don’t understand the meaning of the word.
- ekianjo 9y agoOh really ? http://www.dictionary.com/browse/forced http://www.dictionary.com/browse/forced > enforced or compulsory Is the first definition of the word. How was it compulsory for Norway to comply? They had their officials at gunpoint?
- dragonwriter 9y agoWhy are you using an adjective def for a verb (past tense of the verb “force".) Two different (related) words... Also, words often have more than just their first definition.
- gambiting 9y agoI don't understand the problem with the word forcing here. If you take your kid's xbox to make them clean their room then yeah, you are forcing them to do it.
- ekianjo 9y agoNo you are not. They can decide to live without it.
- gambiting 9y agoHa! Now that would be something. So China is not forcing Norway because Norway can just choose to not trade with China? That's some extremely bizzare logic there.
- andrepd 9y agoWell, yes? They could choose to put their foot down instead of bending over backwards in appeasement. They they would trade with everybody else in the world but China. They chose not to go that way, but unless trade with China is a critical, indispensable part of their survival, no, they were not forced.
- polotics 9y agoChina is currently being run by bullies. Luckily the regime is not long-term sustainable, they are badly failing on innovation, which makes sense considering that the fruit of much hard work can get easily stolen by said bullies.
- oytis 9y agoI think it depends on whether you believe in free trade or not. If you think that every country's business has a right to make deals with any other country's business then Chinese government is depraving Norvegian fishers from what is rightfully theirs and is "forcing" Norwegian government to support their claims on Taiwan. If on the contrary you believe that every government has a right to establish any rules for external trade relationships it likes, then it's more like a free market. Either you buy access to Chinese consumers for recogition of Chinese claims for Taiwan or you don't, it's your choise.
- robert_foss 9y agoApplying pressure that is irresistible is the literal definition of forcing. So yes, China was definitely forcing Norway to recognize Taiwan and Hong Kong as a being a part of China.
- ekianjo 9y agoIts rather a matter of incentives. Norway has more to gainthis way. But it is not threatening their existence so forcing is the wrong word to use here. Its just clickbaity.
- andrepd 9y agoBut here the pressure wasn't "irresistible"; they were not being threatened or attacked. They would just be making less money than they do this way. I hardly call that irresistible.
- robert_foss 9y agoFinancial force is force.
- andai 9y agoWhat is it called when all it takes to convince you to do something you consider unethical is the promise of money?
- StavrosK 9y ago> Forcing would be done via a military operation leaving little choice. I mean, they'd still have the option of denying the one China and going to war, by your definition. Basically, the way you see it, nobody can force you to do anything, as you can always kill yourself.
- ekianjo 9y agoI'd seriously doubt not recognizing China would lead them to war with them. So therefore there were still clearly able to continue on the previous line of thought.
- tristor 9y agoI'm not sure I agree with you, but for what it's worth I do understand the point you are making. You are making a separation between types of pressure which are existential and those which are not. Norway could have accepted the lower exports on fish (less than 1% of their GDP) and continued on while snubbing China, but it was more beneficial to them economically to concede. However, this isn't existential because even if China refuses to trade with Norway entirely, through the EEA the Norwegian people could continue receiving goods from China mediated through a different EEA country that has trade agreements. At it's most dire what occurred simply wasn't an existential threat to Norway and the geographical distance meant that military reactions to trade disputes simply weren't going to occur. Thus the "force" here was mostly one of appearances, rather than reality. That said, I'm not entirely sure I agree that this doesn't meet the definition of "forcing". Politics is squishy like that. Just because fishing is less than 1% of the GDP doesn't mean it has minimal impact on Norwegian society. The fishing industry has significant historical and cultural significance to Norway and abandoning support of that industry could very well be political suicide within Norway for the politicians that refused to play ball. You could say its simply spineless, but the optics of them snubbing China and at the same time snubbing their own fishing industry aren't especially good.
- fpoling 9y agoThere are 2 fishing industries in Norway. One is traditional one and another one is factory farming of fish. The latter appeared around 1980, earned a lot of money and bought disproportionate amount of influence. The industry treats the fish in absolutely evil way, a complete opposite of how traditional fish men relate to the fish.