5 ms·
> Instead they should think about systems where such a breach is just not possible. The underlying problem is the existence of centralized identity, as opposed
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> Instead they should think about systems where such a breach is just not possible.
The underlying problem is the existence of centralized identity, as opposed to decentralized identity. It's the practice of identifying people by a single global identifier (e.g. SSN) instead of having your bank identify you with your bank card and your employer identify you with your employee ID.
People are focused on identity theft here, but there are two points about that. The first is that identity theft doesn't exist without centralized identity, and the second is that identity theft isn't even the main issue.
Centralized databases know very private things about you. They know if you've paid for services at an abortion clinic or a cancer treatment center or a mental health facility. They know if you've ever been on the payroll of a police department, or paid tuition at a police academy, even if you're currently working undercover. They know whether you patronize gay establishments, even if you're in the closet. They know your current address, even if you have a crazy ex who doesn't.
That kind of information is inherently dangerous. In the wrong hands it can get innocent people fired or blackmailed or killed. Which means any central database containing all of it for everyone is inherently a huge vulnerability waiting to be exploited. And none of that goes away even if you replace the SSN with some kind of public key that doesn't itself need to be kept secret.
But centralized identity is the linchpin of those databases and it isn't really needed for anything else. So we should get rid of it.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt's a tricky issue but maybe we could make it illegal to store that data and instead you can release your data temporarily as needed.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoIn other words decentralized identity? There is no reason to have Bank A release your credit history with them to Equifax just so Equifax can release it to Bank B. Cut out the middle man and just ask Bank A release the information to Bank B.
- colejohnson66 9y agoBut how does Bank A know to ask Bank B? That’s what Equifax and friends help with: aggregating the data (and then putting a number to it). It’s a great idea, but how would you implement it? If you cut out the middleman, banks will just form their own centralized system that holds all that data making it easier to access, and... oh, we’re right back where we started.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> But how does Bank A know to ask Bank B? Because you tell them to. When you're applying for credit with a new bank, you ask the existing bank to vouch for your history of making timely payments. In theory the person applying for credit could keep one set of accounts that they always pay and another set which is delinquent but not disclosed, but not disclosing delinquent accounts would be fraud and anyone willing to commit fraud has been able to commit identity theft this whole time without the system collapsing.
- Joeri 9y agoThere’s no effective taxation without centralized identity, so unless we move to a system of anarchy it won’t happen.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoVAT is collected entirely by businesses and doesn't require individuals to be identified at all. And it's possible to have de facto progressive taxation without having any income tax by combining VAT or similar with a universal basic income. Alternatively, it's possible to have a tax ID which is used only for taxes and prohibited by law from being used for anything else.
- moomin 9y agoI don’t think it is possible. The effective tax rate for billionaires under a scheme such as you propose would still be pretty much zero. The only way to make that a progressive tax scheme is to have zero or negative tax revenue.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoIf they spend the money they would have to pay VAT. If they invest it in something then the invested in company spends it and they would have to pay VAT. The only way to avoid it is to stick the cash in a mattress, which nobody really does because it's more profitable to make $1 in profit at the cost of paying $.35 in VAT than to make no profit and pay no taxes. They could avoid local taxes by investing offshore, but they do that already.
- moomin 9y agoI think you're misunderstanding me. I'm not denying you can raise income through VAT, I'm saying you can't do it in a progressive manner, basic income or no basic income. The reason for this is that the more you earn, the less you spend as a proportion of your income. Billionaires spend almost nothing compared to either their income or their wealth. The poorest in society spend everything, because some things are essential. Any progressive system would make it so that the less well off paid _at most_ as much as the 1%.* Income tax may not work very well, but it's one of the most progressive forms of taxation there is. *And yeah, as you point out, tax avoidance makes a mockery of this anyway.
- pwg 9y ago> The underlying problem is the existence of centralized identity, as opposed to decentralized identity. There is also an underlying problem of reliance upon publicly available information (and in many cases, one's SSN is publicly available, even before this breach) to authenticate that human body X claiming to be John Smith is in fact actually the John Smith. Public facts, such as SSN, mothers maiden name, or name of first employer, etc. have been relied upon as "secret, known only to John Smith" items for authentication purposes when in reality those facts were never really secret in the first place. The only reason those facts even worked as authentication devices is that pre-internet/pre-google it was exceedingly hard to look most of them up in the public records. Doing so often involved physical travel to multiple disparate archives and physical search through archived paper. And so if unknown human X knew all three it was highly likely X was John Smith because otherwise X had put in an awful lot of effort. Today, with the internet/google, obtaining almost all of these facts from the public records where they have always existed to begin with involves typing in searches, zero physical travel, and no combing through archived paper. The internet has simply exposed the Emperor's New Clothes [1] for what they really were all along. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor%27s_New_Clothes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor%27s_New_Clothes