4 ms·
While I have my opinions on Oracle, I don't have any insight into their corporate health. Were I an investor, though, things like this would alarm me greatly. I
by kstrauser 9y ago
While I have my opinions on Oracle, I don't have any insight into their corporate health. Were I an investor, though, things like this would alarm me greatly. It comes across very much like "we can no longer compete on any remotely level playing field and need the law to prop us up." Coupled with statements about their cloud services that are outright delusional (for example, http://www.businessinsider.com/larry-ellison-on-oracle-cloud-and-amazon-web-services-2016-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/larry-ellison-on-oracle-cloud...), I get the impression that they're struggling mightily. What's the mood really like inside Oracle these days?
- ProAm 9y ago> "we can no longer compete on any remotely level playing field and need the law to prop us up" That is a huge assumption. In reality they are just positioning themselves, they are a business and government contracts are always extremely juicy and profitable. Oracle is just after the $$.
- FilterSweep 9y agoA huge assumption, yes, but the article backs it up with its source article which maintains that Oracle is failing to hit earnings targets due to the influence of Open Source competition [0] For me, I would feasibly agree that their comments are good positioning, however the vehement attack on Open Source, in particular, sounds more like the canary in the coal mine. [0] http://www.techrepublic.com/article/oracles-rising-open-source-problem/ http://www.techrepublic.com/article/oracles-rising-open-sour...
- AndyNemmity 9y agoDoes it back it up? That article, cites another article, which cites another article, all saying they are opinions. The last is behind a paywall. I mean, I agree with the argument that there's an impact, but that isn't a citation for it.
- ProAm 9y agoThey are worried about share price and what to speak to at their quarterly meetings (See their recent push for cloud revenue), they are still making a LOT of money. They are merely courting government with this plea. They are one of the largest tech companies in the world so gov will listen to their 'expert' advice (whether it be true or just good for their bottom line) and sign contracts because of it. Sort of like IBM these days. Open source has a long way to go to really be a threat to Oracle. But if you are going to paint a bad guy, open source might as well be it, who is going to argue on their behalf to the government and get a ear that will listen?
- AndyNemmity 9y agoI don't get that impression all, they sell government software. It's in their interest to do the best to position that software. As an investor, I'd be concerned if they weren't doing this.
- sbov 9y agoThe comments from all other companies are here: https://github.com/GSA/modernization/issues https://github.com/GSA/modernization/issues Read a few of them. None of them I've sampled are as aggressive, towards promoting themselves and denigrating other solutions, as Oracle's was.
- AndyNemmity 9y agoFantastic reading, thanks for adding legitimate detail to the discussion. The tone is very different as you noted.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Clubber 9y agoIt's difficult to compete with free, even if (and I'm not saying it is) the free version is substandard. I'm sure the federal government is budget conscious with the current administration.
- eduren 9y agoWhat I worry about is whether their "budgetary consciousness" can outweigh lobbying efforts by contractors. If there's one thing this administration loves, it's big deals with big companies. That's what gets the headlines.
- banku_brougham 9y agoThis was very amusing to read. I dont detect any sarcasm. I'll posit a non-partisan and opposite view: the federal government is not budget conscious under any administration.
- gph 9y agoOh their conscious alright... conscious that they want to add more for everything their side supports while cutting everything the other side supports. Of course after all the political theater this usually ends up with them adding what they want but getting blocked at cutting anything.
- cosinetau 9y agoI don't think that's the case at all. I would expect more quid pro quo out of the current administration, especially if Oracle could paint Silicon Valley as a "leftist wasteland," which it probably already believes.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I'm sure the federal government is budget conscious with the current administration. Based on...what? Certainly, the current administration is opposed to much of the non-defense, non-criminal-law-enforcement function of the federal government, and eager to cite budget concerns in that context, but I don't see much evidence that it is generally budget conscious beyond that.
- davidgerard 9y agoyeah, this read to me like Oracle's "Postgres Marketing Department" springing into action once more.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bufordsharkley 9y ago> "we can no longer compete on any remotely level playing field" Competing on level playing fields results in efficient markets, which asymptotically trends towards profits going to zero. Investors don't want honest competition, they want exploitable privilege.
- Yhippa 9y agoIntuit's Quicken tax software comes to mind.
- thisisit 9y agoWe use on-prem Oracle stuff but had to evaluate the Oracle Cloud versions recently. I can't speak for how they stack up against AWS. But they couldn't even compare with the on-prem versions. Cloud versions were very different and nearly alien to the users of the on-prem versions. Not to mention the huge downtimes, they wanted nearly 12 hours every alternate weekend. The cost difference was lower for cloud but finally the company opted for on-prem versions. That said, as an investor, I doubt someone would look this as negative as "we can no longer compete on any remotely level playing field and need the law to prop us up." Given my limited knowledge of Oracle and Larry Ellison's marketing tactic, this would just be in a long line of marketing speak trying to portray everything non-Oracle in bad light. If White House follows up on the marketing speak, they get a lot of government contracts and makes a lot of money. This is good for me as a shareholder. What would concern me, again with limited knowledge of Ellison and Oracle, is if they just rolled over and played dead and pretended that OSS and SV were not a threat to their business. That as an investor would send the alarm bells ringing.