3 ms·
Sorry to be the luddite, but these devices just seem like first-world-only interest to me. I have no desire to automate my house (I can see why others do). I
by r00fus 9y ago
Sorry to be the luddite, but these devices just seem like first-world-only interest to me.
I have no desire to automate my house (I can see why others do). I don't have a home alarm. I have one TV in the house for several kids.
The day planner/shopping list is good, but I pull out my phone instead and speak to it (when I press home button).
Finally, is everyone really comfortable having always-on listening in their home? The convenience/creepy ratio just doesn't seem prudent for me. It's amusing to see how privacy oriented HN is yet these devices are so popular here - they're an unaudited vector into your most private moments.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Sorry to be the luddite, but these devices just seem like first-world-only interest to me. Probably mostly, but so what? The first world is over a billion people.
- Eridrus 9y ago> It's amusing to see how privacy oriented HN is yet these devices are so popular here - they're an unaudited vector into your most private moments. HN is an echo chamber where it's not even worth talking about trade-offs when it comes to privacy, all I ever get from it is downvotes.
- Klathmon 9y agoWell I can tell you why I'm okay with it. Google says (and i've somewhat validated) that data isn't sent to their servers until you say the "keyword". And they do allow you to view and delete any previously sent speech from your account, and I do trust them about that as the backlash from not actually deleting it when they said they would could be pretty bad (and they could be in some pretty deep legal trouble as well). And if the worry is that they can update it to be "always recording and uploading", they (or another adversary) can already do that with the other phones, laptops, and other devices in the house (most likely more easily). It's a tradeoff, but it's one that I and my family are comfortable making. Just like how you can choose to not go outside and keep your privacy that way, I find the benefits and usefulness of these products are worth the loss in privacy for me. And that loss in privacy is controllable by me (they can be turned off, unplugged, or shut down whenever I want). That being said, things like the home-automation are as local as possible. Everything is run via local-network-only systems (zwave, wifi, bluetooth, zigbee), and then "external" systems are added on (like the google home). So i'm not trusting quite as much as people assume I am to some other company, and there are things I will not trust to 3rd parties (like i'm still not comfortable putting surveillance camera footage on anything I don't own myself).
- mikeash 9y agoWhat's the difference between having something like Google Home in your home and carrying a cell phone in your pocket, other than the fact that the cell phone can listen in on you even when you're away from home? I really don't get why everyone carries listening devices 24/7 and then freaks out about these smart speakers.
- r00fus 9y agoOne is designed to be listening at all times, the other one may not even have the explicit capability (I turn off voice-activated Google/Siri on all my devices). Trigger words can be accidentally spoken, they can be spoken by other devices, etc. Hidden trigger words can exist. I think it's logical fallacy of extremes to say that carrying an e.g. iPhone is an equivalent security exposure to having GoogleHome/HomePod/Echos littered around your house, just because they both "could" be hacked/backdoored.
- colecut 9y agoSaying that phones "could" be hacked/backdoored is no more of a fallacy than saying Hidden trigger words "can" exist.
- mikeash 9y agoMany (most? all?) modern smartphones are designed to be listening at all times too. You turn this off on all your devices. Do you trust the manufacturer to actually stop listening when you do? I don’t see how it’s a logical fallacy to point out that there’s another device with the same capablilities that most of the complainers don’t give a second thought to. I really don’t understand how the risk from something like Google Home is any higher than the risk from a smartphone.